Councillor David Silvester Apologises and Does Not Resign

Source: BBC
Around 40 members of the public turned up to the extraordinary meeting of the Town Council last night to discuss the views of Councillor David Silvester in his letter to the Editor of the Henley Standard, published on Friday 17 January. There were no signs of any angry protesters with placards outside (as reported in some national media) and it was good to see that the police presence which had been put in place was not needed.
At the start of meeting the Mayor, Stefan Gawrysiak, read out the motion “That the views expressed by Councillor David Silvester in his letter to the Editor of Henley Standard, published on 17 January, were his personal views and not the views of the Henley-on-Thames Town Council and are not Council policy.”
The public question and answer session heard both people being supportive of Councillor Silvester and those very upset about his views. Some people however decided that instead of addressing Councillor Silvester’s letter – which was the point of the meeting – that they should express their views on what actually causes flooding and that Councillors shouldn’t ignore this!
Other more focused views and statements made included:
- “Why is the Council wasting their time and money on this?”
- “We live in democratic society which allows freedom of speech.”
- “Mr Silvester’s quotation was from the Old Testament and the New Testament clearly states that you should love thy neighbour.”
- “Mr Silvester represents our town and has misused his position and trust.”
- “If the comments were racist, his comments would have been treated very differently.”
- “Mr Silvester spoke as a practising Christian and he spoke to David Cameron about this.”
Stefan Gawrysiak explained that this extraordinary meeting had been called to allow the public to discuss this issue because at the Full Council Meeting on 18 February nothing can be debated that isn’t already on the agenda. The Town Council however have no powers to take any disciplinary action but it has passed 12 complaints on to South Oxfordshire District Council, who will decide whether he should be investigated for a possible breach of the Councillors’ code of conduct.
Sarah Butcher from Belle Vue Road, who started an online petition for the resignation of Councillor Silvester, said “UKIP have now expelled Councillor Silvester and 25,000 people have now signed the petition. This shows that a large proportion of the community no longer want Councillor Silvester to represent them. He has caused a lot of hurt in the large gay community in Henley.”
Councillor Silvester then replied, “I wrote this letter on the 29 December (Editor Comment – 3 weeks before it was actually published) and it was not my intention to embarrass Henley town or insult the gay community and I apologise to them if personal insult has been their perception. My views were directed at the Government. I have a number of friends who are gay. I will be more circumspect in what I write in the future in an open forum and I reject the petition to resign. I was elected for four years and I will serve out my term.”
The Henley Town Councillors then had the opportunity to express their views and most of them confirmed that these were Councillor Silvester’s own views and not theirs or the Council’s. None of them supported the resignation of Councillor Silvester and many of them said what a good Councillor he had been. Councillor Will Hamilton proposed that an amendment should be added to the motion, namely that ”Councillor Silvester should make an apology”, but this was not seconded probably due to the fact that he apologised earlier! The original motion was passed.
Mayor Stefan Gawyrisak thanked the assembled audience for their measured views and tones during the public session. He said, “Rightly or wrongly the Henley Standard chose to add Henley Town Council after Councillor Silvester’s name but we need to move forward and Councillor Silvester has said that in future he will be more circumspect about his views. In a democratic society, we all have different views and should respect each other’s.”
It was disappointing that no-one raised the point that the Henley Standard should not have added “Henley Town Council” to Councillor Silvester’s letter (as he did not include it) because the addition of those words implied Silvester’s views were those of the Council (and he has made it clear they were not, but were his personal opinions), and perhaps the paper should publicly apologise to the Town Council for the misrepresentation it caused by this alteration?



