Gillotts’ Responds to Trevor Howell’s Plan B

Chair of Governors at Gillotts School, David Gorsuch has replied to Trevor Howell’s Plan B below:
“I am delighted that Trevor Howell has brought up these questions. I am sure they are in the minds of many people and this gives us a chance to respond. A fuller response is on the school Web site but I have given brief responses to his questions here.”
Is £10 million a realistic estimate for the refurbishment of Gillotts?
We believe it is. In July 2013, we commissioned Gerry Lytle Associates, a firm of architects specialising in the education sector, to carry out an analysis of the state of the school’s facilities and opportunities for improving them. Their completed ‘masterplan’ is summarised in a document available on the school’s website (Home -> More announcements -> Joint Henley and Harpsden Neighbourhood Plan -> schoolplan.pdf). They have done a thorough job, including five visits to the school, discussions with all of the staff and commissioning surveys of the land and the trees. It’s based on this and their experience of similar projects in similar schools that they have come up with the cost of £10 million. We think it is as reliable a costing as it is possible to come up with at this stage.
Will the Secretary of State give permission to sell the land?
There are no guarantees of course but we have a strong case because we have so much land. Our proposed ‘master plan’ will actually improve the school’s sporting provision rather than reduce it and we will still have more land than would be expected for a school our size. So we feel pretty confident. And other schools are doing this. Just down the road, Great Marlow recently completed something similar. They now have sports and teaching facilities that I envy!
Can the school prove that there will be no loss of playing field capacity or sports facilities? Is the rearrangement of the facilities realistic? It looks very tight. Will the sloping area be levelled? Did the consultants who drew up the plan work from a paper plan only when allocating the facilities or did they physically appraise the site?
Yes we can prove that there will be no loss of playing field capacity or sports facilities. As I mentioned above, the architects visited and walked the site five times and have had several discussions with the PE staff. Based on this, they have drawn up plans for pitch layouts on the land we are not planning to sell. They have demonstrated that, because we do different sports in summer and winter, we can provide the same sporting facilities on less land. The topographic survey has shown that some levelling will be desirable but this is taken into account. The installation of the MUGA (multi-use games area or all weather pitch) and our continued access to the leisure centre will mean we have better overall sporting provision than we have now.
Would St Mary’s and Sacred Heart schools want access to Gillotts playing fields?
Neither of these schools has ever asked to use our playing fields. If they do, we will be happy to discuss it, whether we sell land or not.
Is there really no other way to raise the money? Is the school open to alternative funding options? Did they apply to the ACMF (Academies Capital Maintenance Fund) 2014/15 round? Will they apply in 2015/16?
Over the years, we have continually looked for money to invest in the school. Since becoming an academy we have applied for ACMF funding each year and we will continue to do. So far, we have been extremely successful. We have had £110,000 to deal with emergency repairs to pipes and drains plus £500,000 for refurbishment of the gym, replacement of faulty fan convector heaters and repair of leaking roofs. In the 2014/15 round, we applied for £700,000 to deal with interior underground heating pipework but were only awarded £89,000 – we are appealing.
The problem is that, as the name suggests, the ACMF is a maintenance fund. We have looked at other potential sources of funding and consulted with other schools that have attempted fundraising. It has become clear that it is very difficult and it would be virtually impossible to raise the kind of money we need for the rejuvenation project.
To be clear, nobody in the school wants to sell part of our land. We will all find it painful. However, we feel we have a responsibility to do so in support of the interests of the young people of Henley.


