World War One Christmas Truce – It Really Happened
As we near the end of the World War One Commemorative year, we thought this article from Mike Willoughby from the Henley Lest We Forget Project really reflects the Christmas message for many, Peace on Earth and Goodwill to all Men. We will remember them…
In early January 1915, Sidney Smart of 78 Reading Road, Henley received a letter from his son Staff Sergeant Herbert Smart 2nd Battalion Wiltshire Regiment (machine gun section). On Christmas Eve 1914 he was in the front line trenches at Fleurbaix, a village situated five kilometres southwest of Armentieres in the Pas-de-Calais in France. In the letter Herbert says on 24th about 6pm they saw a lot of Chinese lanterns hung up all along the German trenches which were only about 300-350 feet from the British lines. There was also a lot of singing going on, but no firing, so we started singing too. It was a frosty night and every word coming from the German trenches could be heard quite clearly. All in all it was a quiet night, hardly a shot being fired. At 5am on Christmas Day the Germans began shouting “Merry Xmas” across “no man’s land” and of course the British shouted back.
Herbert and his pals were not able to see the opposing trenches due to fog but several of them started walking about on the top of the trenches. The order was given not to fire unless the Germans did. About 9am they started walking towards our trenches and we met them half way, they shook hands and greetings were exchanged. You would not have thought it was war, it was just like a break in a military exercise. Herbert was given a small watch by one of the German officers. He also had a chat with a chap who was a professor of languages and lived at Stratford-on-Avon before the war. He told Herbert that they were fed up with the war. The German also said that “We are shaking hands now, but tonight or tomorrow we will be shooting at one another again.” They had also brought cigarettes with them which they gave to the British soldiers. Herbert sent some home to his father, who was particularly surprised to see they were “Duke of Edinburgh” brand, the name of his son’s regiment. According to Herbert nearly all of the Germans had the Iron Cross which in his opinion was “as cheap as dirt”.
One of the enemy stated that they had captured nearly all of the Russian soldiers and were only waiting for England as regards peace. Herbert thought that England would never come to terms, not even half-way. He thought that the enemy had their heads filled with all sorts of tales and he would like to have told them the truth. Later in the day the Germans carried the bodies of some English soldiers who had been killed in a previous raid into the middle of no man’s land and the British were able to bury them. The Germans did the same with their casualties. Eventually the men said their farewells and returned to the trenches. The rest of the day was quiet, cold but that was better than all of the rain they had recently, at least the mud was now frozen.


