Another Delay to Neighbourhood Plan – Councillors Vote to Wait for Transport Strategy
After nearly 2 years of research, questionnaires, working groups and consultations Nexus Planning thought they had the final submission of the Joint Harpsden and Henley Neighbourhood Plan ready to be sent to SODC. A special Full Council Meeting was held last night to receive and consider whether the submission should be approved.
Three members of the public; Malcolm Dodds, Trevor Howell and Catherine Allan-Notaras raised a number of concerns including the definition of affordable housing, flexibility of the plan, the inclusion of Gillotts’ School playing fields, small business development and whether there was enough detail in the Plan to protect the environment and open spaces.
Matthew Kinghan from Nexus Planning gave a presentation which gave a summary of the Neighbourhood Plan process, time plan, results from the 2015 consultation, main issues arising from the 2015 consultation and how they have been addressed plus a time plan going forward.
A summary of the consultation results showed that 73% of responses endorsed the Plan, including 40% who added a comment under ‘Yes, subject to….’ with the most frequently mentioned ‘subject to…’ housing sites on Gillotts’ School playing fields and the Fair Mile site.
Matthew then talked through the main issues of concern from the consultation and how they had been addressed:
Gillotts School – this is a housing reserve site and the school has to meet the objection raised by Sport England by 1 January 2020 to meet National Planning Policy Framework requirements to replace the playing fields. It has been included because it supports the Core Strategy and the distribution of development.
Fair Mile – supports strategy of spreading development around town. The amended policy will meet English Heritage recommendations and the QC opinion is that the site’s inclusion does not conflict with the Listed Buildings Act.
Highlands Farm – it is a large brownfield site, an amended policy has been met to meet OCC archaeological requirements and the plan is committed to sustainable transport solutions within a constrained spending environment.
357 Reading Road (next to Tesco) – there will not be retail units at this location, there will be retail units at the mixed development at Stuart Turner/Empstead Works
Transport Strategy – Concerns about transport and traffic management has been the main theme of consultation throughout – it was the biggest issue in the first consultation. Henley Town Council has funded its own Transport Strategy as it has had no support from OCC who are responsible for the highways.
Click here to see the full presentation
Councillor Will Hamilton proposed that the Council should approve the full submission version of the Plan to the SODC which had been approved by the Neighbourhood Governance Committee and Councillor Martin Akehurst seconded this proposal.
Councillor Stefan Gawrysiak then said that in fact the minutes of the Neighbourhood Governance Committee stated that the just the housing sites had been approved and not the full submission version of the Plan itself. He then proposed a new amendment for the Council to vote on – The Full Submission Version of the Joint Henley and Harpsden Neighbourhood Plan should be not be submitted until after the results have been received from the Transport survey and a strategy from this be included in the submission.
Matthew Kinghan of Nexus Planning at this point, pointed out that delaying the submission would mean that South Oxfordshire becomes vulnerable to speculative development and means that sites not even in the plan may be granted planning permission on appeal and the Plan would probably require more consultation and incur more expense.
A recorded vote then took place with Councillors Abey, Eggleton, Gawrysiak, Hinton, Reismann, Miller, Smewing, Smith and Thomas voting for this amendment making it 9 for and 7 against. At this point there was a gasp from the public gallery as Councillors Smith and Thomas had voted against the Conservative proposal. Councillor Dylan Thomas had several times stood up during the debate to say that he did not agree with the housing sites at the Fairmile and so did many of his voters he had canvassed. He also felt that transport provision was important. Councillor Nimmo-Smith was not in attendance.
Councillor Jane Smewing then proposed an amendment for changing some of words in the Submission of the Plan. The Town Clerk, Mike Kennedy at this point jumped in and suggested that if Councillors need more time to review the wording then another Special Full Council meeting would be needed to review these and asked that any amendments to the wording should be submitted in writing prior to this meeting. Again a recorded vote was taken and the outcome was the same as the first amendment with the same voters for and the result being 9-7.
The public referendum was due to take place in October/November with the Full Submission Version of the Plan now – this looks more likely to be now in early 2016? The Councillors all though did agree on one thing and that was that the public needed to say YES to the plan at the referendum.


