Townlands Steering Group Make Statement to Scrutiny Committee on Flaws in Consultation and Agree Action Plan
Last week the Townlands Steering Group Committee met in the Town Hall to discuss their Action Plan against the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) to reduce the number of beds at the new Townlands hospital from 18 that were in the original Business Case approved in 2012.
At the start of the meeting the ‘Statement’ that Councillor Ian Reissmann, Chair of the TSG Committee would present to the Oxfordshire Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (HOSC) meeting the next day about the flaws in the Consultation process was discussed.
The final 3-minute statement agreed and presented to HOSC by Councillor Reissmann on 2 July was, “I would like to thank the Committee for inviting me to speak today. The community and the TSG believe that the CCG consultation was flawed and, if implemented will lead to a significant risk to the health of the inhabitants of Oxfordshire. We urge the CCG to revert to the plan as approved in the original Business Case that was approved by the PCT and SHA in 2012.
The TSG have the following concerns (summary):
Beds – limited usage data available and provided late into the consultation and the modelling results did not take into account actual patients in other Acute Hospitals. The 3 day Rapid Access Care Unit was only introduced at the end of the consultation.
Consultees – What was the response from key consultees and health care providers e.g. Royal Berkshire Hospital and GPs in SE Oxon who do not support the CCG proposal
Alternative Beds in Care Home – no confirmation that there is alternative provision for beds at new Order of St John Care home or different levels of health care needed
Resources to treat patients at home – no quantification of additional resource required, taking into account needs and travel time.
Consultation Document and Questionnaire – no question in Questionnaire about whether people believe beds are necessary. It asked leading questions which made it impossible to oppose the plans
Transition Plans – no attempt to explain how the move to the new model will take place or commitment to monitor new model
To read the full statement by Councillor Reissmann click here
Councillor Reissmann said afterwards, “The HOSC Chair proposed noting the report adding in that the consultation carried out was ‘adequate’. There were blank looks and somewhat anti-climactically, no one opposed this, but it was barely a formal vote and was ’nodded through’. I was told very clearly this morning by a senior member of the CCG that the die was cast and current proposals would be going to the CCG Board on 30th July.
County Councillor David Nimmo Smith also made a statement which included “Madam Chairman, your Committee is scrutinising the process as you do not make decisions. But what the Community seeks is a reassurance that their medical needs will be fully addressed in the model being proposed by the CCG. The consultation did not give that. Neither of the heads of the 2 Henley medical practices have endorsed the CCG model. The community concerns, volubly expressed at the meetings I attended, have been pushed aside in the report. They think that the consultation was incomplete and flawed, and that the rush to get the building filled as soon as it has been completed is at the expense of a robust plan and appropriate consultation.” To read Councillor Nimmo Smith’s full statement click here.
The preliminary key finding results from the CCG Consultation have been published and can be viewed here.
The Action Plan agreed at the TSG meeting:
- Publicise the March on Saturday 11 July at 10am starting from Market Place through all media including Social Media
- Committee to write to local MPs John Howell and Teresa May, Health Secretary and the Prime Minister
- Urge the public to lobby John Howell MP by writing to him at howell@oxfordshireconservatives.com

- TSG to write an article/press release to send to National newspapers
- TSG to distribute petitions to all local shops. Investigate whether this could be then be handed into Downing Street
- TSG to make an official request under the Freedom of Information Act to get bed data and modelling data from CCG Consultation so that TSG can produce own report and findings for presentation to the HOSC and CCG
- Seek and obtain legal advice on obtaining an injunction and judicial revew against the new model
- Fundraise – get a team together to fundraise for money to pay for potential legal advice and other campaign activities. Look at Friends of Townlands Community Hospital charity registration to see if a collection can be made at the campaign march and obtain licence (licence now obtained), investigate crowd funding and online donation giving
- TSG to set up meetings with other hospitals to get their views/data e.g. Chipping Norton where the CCG have also recently proposed that a Care Home Trust takes over the town’s NHS Intermediary Care Beds.


