Townlands Proposals Discussed at Health Overview Scrutiny Committee Meeting
Our County Councillor David Nimmo Smith spoke yesterday at the Oxfordshire Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (HOSC) meeting on the new model for Townlands.
Below are extracts from David’s speech…
“As you will be aware, the CCG is promoting a model of care which will, at the end of a transition phase, result in intermediate care being provided in the on site care home rather than a hospital, before patients are able to return to their homes. Despite a number of meetings since your July HOSC, the Townlands Steering Group (TSG) is still not fully convinced that the intermediate care proposed is in the best long term interests of the communities served by Townlands hospital.
It is important to emphasise that we want to continue to work with the CCG to get the best medical pathway and provision for the Oxfordshire residents in the Townlands catchment area. The dossier you should have received yesterday by email contains the TSG proposals for combining a RACU with a bedded service. The key question is the manner in which the new model is deployed and whether it is successful or not. The TSG would like to help in any way it can with this process in order to reassure the community that the new arrangements are at least as good as the existing. I hope your discussions are able to consider this point. And that the CCG continues to involve us in the process.
Our nearest acute hospital is in Reading. We are pleased that the Royal Berks Hospital is working with the service commissioners to assess the impact of the bed model. However, until that is concluded, they have told us they remain concerned about the impact of the proposals on them.”
David Nimmo Smith spoke with David Smith, Chief Executive of Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group afterwards, and emphasised that the TSG is keen to help in the monitoring process. Yvonne Constance, Chair of the HSOC told David that her Committee does not have the resources to do this on its own. Yvonne said, “She would much rather it be monitored at a more local level.”
David said after the meeting, “The subsequent HOSC debate was wide ranging and explored the county wide provision of beds and services. Which is not consistent. The CCG conceded that it is a confusing picture and that the Oxfordshire model needs new ways of working. Whilst an overall strategy is being prepared before it goes out for consultation, this is a luxury not available in Henley as the hospital building is nearing completion and the TSG needs to get their new services in place, in the new way of working. Both the CCG and County Council are aware that staffing is a challenge, whichever plan is in place, as care packages are increasing at 10% per year. The meeting was advised that nursing staff for the intermediate beds in the Care Home will be fully trained, with the correct level of support staff.”
Chair of Townlands Steering Group, Councillor Ian Reissman said afterwards, “I was encouraged by the approach HOSC took at its meeting yesterday (17 September) to consider the Townlands proposals in the context of a county wide plan to provide health care generally and bedded care specifically.”
“Although Townlands is a special case by virtue of having a hospital being built right now, many in the community do not understand how critical decisions, such as not providing beds in the new hospital, can be taken until the county wide plan is drawn up.”
“The county wide plan will need to have the support of clinicians and all stakeholders. The CCG proposals for Townlands have been submitted to the CCG board for approval despite the strongly voiced concerns of local GPs and Royal Berks Hospital. Even at this stage the TSG strongly urge the CCG to revert to the plans as approved in the Business Case of 2012 in which beds are reprovided in the hospital. The TSG will then work with the CCG, HOSC and other stakeholders to ensure Townlands services are designed in the context of a county wide plan so that the services in Henley and this part of South Oxfordshire meet the health needs of the community. The advantages of doing this in a way that is not against the artificially imposed deadline of the new hospital opening are obvious.”
“The TSG proposals also remove the need to open beds at Wallingford while the Care Home opens in June 2016 which is where the CCG proposals will place the Intermediate and Rapid Access Care Unit beds.”
I am also pleased that the HOSC considered how the new services could be monitored and scrutinised after being implemented to ensure that the services operate safely and provide care that is at least as good as the current system. The HSOC view that this should be carried out at a “Local Level” is shared by the TSG which will be keen to help to support this work.”
A public meeting to discuss Townlands is being held next Monday (21 September) at 7.30pm at the Christchurch Centre on Reading Road.



