Beds in Care Home Instead of New Hospital
At the CCG Board meeting on Thursday in Oxford, the Board made a final decision to lease 8 beds in the new Order of St John Care (OSJ) home which will open next June with up to 6 more beds leased on demand.
Before the meeting the Townlands Steering Group (TSG) presented a dossier which asked for:
- provide 14 beds at the start (i.e. when the OSJ opens) as per the existing Peppard Ward
- provide guarantees on OSJ staffing: care assistants and registered nurses
- reinstate the Consultant to lead the RACU
Full document can be read here
At the Board meeting, Chair of the TSG, Councillor Ian Reissman made a speech…
“We are concerned that the proposals in front of you today are unnecessarily risky and incomplete.”
“In the course of meetings, the community and TSG have reluctantly, and with misgivings, agreed to work with the CCG to address community concerns on the CCG proposals. As a result there have been a number of clarifications and modifications to the CCG’s plans over recent weeks. However, there remain a small number of key issues which have so far proved intractable. In particular the number of leased beds when the OSJ opens in June/July 2016. As you can see in the dossier, we do not believe that the data and modelling of need for beds is sufficiently robust. We are also concerned about the quality of care available in the beds leased from the Care Home compared to an NHS operated bedded facility as originally planned.”
“We believe these proposals threaten the safe delivery of health care.”
As a result of the decision Councillor Ian Reissmann told the Governing Body that the TSG and community did not support the CCG proposals.
David Smith, Chief Executive of the Clinical Commissioning Group, said:
“Given the timescales involved in the development of the new Townlands health campus, it was important to make a decision today. The Governing Body paid very close attention to the assurances that had been put before them and had very important points to make on a number of issues.
“Members were also very clear about the need for close monitoring of progress at Townlands. We will work with the Townlands Steering Group to make sure it plays a role in monitoring the implementation of these proposals, the quality of care provided and the outcomes for patients. We are committed to spending the time needed to make sure we keep a close eye on progress. ”
A public meeting is now being planned for week commencing 5 October when the TSG will report back to the community for them to consider the next steps.
Councillor Reissman said, “The community needs to consider carefully the steps we need to take to ensure we get the best services possible. I am sure some will advocate legal proceedings, i.e. a Judicial Review. The risks of this are significant: apart from the uncertainty and expense of any legal action, we would be excluded from involvement in making the proposed new model operate as well as possible. It is important to remember that the judge cannot consider whether the plan is sound – only that due process has been followed.
“The offer of continued engagement of the TSG from the CCG is real and will make a difference to the eventual services that are deployed.”



