What have Horns and Haloes got to do with Interviewing?
Is a person with a tattoo more likely to turn up late to work than one without? Do attractive people write better copy than those we consider less attractive?
Well, in a famous experiment conducted by two psychologists, Landy and Segall, back in 1974, those reviewing two essays of contrasting quality scored the work significantly higher when they believed the author was attractive.
It’s an example of a trait common to all of us – we often label people based on the existence of only one characteristic. If this characteristic is negative in our minds we too easily attribute other negative traits to the same person, even if we haven’t experienced them – this is the ‘horns’ effect. Similarly, If a candidate says they like gardening in their spare time, – and you do too – you are likely to feel you will ‘obviously’ get on with them in your team at work too. This is an example of the ‘halo’ effect. What is even more important is that we then go on to look for evidence which only proves our opinion – so our judgement can become very distorted. (Hence why first impressions are so important, particularly in business life.) In interviews the Horns and Halo effect can be particularly damaging as it limits our ability to see the true potential of good candidates and the true risk of unqualified candidates. So what can we do to minimise it?
- Awareness of our biases and individual thought processes
- Clear, objective criteria for the role and person being recruited
- Involve a range of interviewers with different perspectives
- Good questions
- A smart range of tests and other activities to assess experience, potential, attitude and cultural fit.
If you are involved in interviewing candidates take time to recognise your biases and invest time in preparing well for the interviews. Involve others to get a balanced view and a fair process for the candidates. If you need specific help with recruiting and interviewing contact Nic Tinsley at Business Fit Club on nic.tinsley@businessfitclub.co.uk or book onto the next Interviewing Skills Workshop on 10 November 10 at Green Park, Reading.




