Henley Town Council Appeal Against McCarthy & Stone Planning Decision
Last Wednesday, SODC approved the application by McCarthy and Stone for an assisted care home at 345 Reading Road, the site of the former Jet Garage which directly conflicts with the Joint Henley and Harpsden Neighbourhood Plan which was democratically approved by 81.7% of those who voted in the 10 March referendum.
Last Friday, Henley Town Council submitted a request to the Department of Communities and Local Government (DCLG) to call in this application. They have the power to do this which they will exercise if the issue is of national interest. DCLG confirmed that they will consider the request.
The Mayor, Councillor Julian Brookes said, “Our MP, John Howell, immediately on his return to the UK on Sunday, wrote to the Minister of State, Gavin Barwell, who is responsible to the Secretary of State for planning and local government, asking him to exercise his powers and call in this application. We know that our contact in DCLG to whom we submitted our request received our MP’s letter via the Minister’s office.”
John Howell wrote, “My purpose in writing to you is to request that you call in the application as it runs contrary to the recently enacted Neighbourhood Plan (the Henley & Harpsden Neighbourhood Plan). I note that there is reference to the Joint Henley and Harpsden Neighbourhood Development Plan (JHHNDP) in the planning papers issued by SODC. However, I am concerned that this is selective and misses the overall spirit of the Plan in overlooking the early chapters of the published Plan. There are no specific policies in the plan regarding care homes but the overall Plan comes out in favour of affordable housing. SODC recently stated that the Henley area is short of over 300 affordable homes. The JHHNP calls for 40% of 500 dwellings to be affordable as set out in the Plan. We cannot afford to lose any of these houses. As the Henley constituency is already at full employment any argument on the basis of employment does not apply unless additional affordable housing is provided.”
Councillor Brookes has confirmed that whilst the SODC planning committee passed the McCarthy & Stone application, albeit on the casting vote of the chairman, the permission is not formally granted until SODC send written confirmation of their decision. DCLG have asked SODC “that the Secretary of State be given an agreed period of time to assess the proposals”, i.e hold off sending their written confirmation of planning permission.
“We will also be applying to DCLG to call in any future planning applications which contravene our neighbourhood plan. There are rumours of more care homes planned where we have allocated housing which in every case requires 40% affordable. We have been in touch with other town and parish councils who have experienced similar problems so that we can learn from their experiences and enjoy their advice and support,” added Councillor Brookes.
Henley Town Council have said they will leave no stone unturned in their initial objective of having this planning application called in. If you have ideas or information, don’t hesitate to send it either to the Mayor, Councillor Julian Brookes, or the Town Clerk, Mrs Janet Wheeler or any town councillor of your choice. The Mayor, concluded, “We supported the Inland Homes application to build 55 apartments, 40% of which affordable, at this site and this is what our Neighbourhood Plan calls for and what we want to see.”



