Care Home Approved on LA Fitness Site
The SODC Planning Committee last night approved the application by Henthames to build an 80 bedded care home on the old LA Fitness site in Newton Road. The vote by the Planning Committee was split 4-4 but the Chair, Felix Bloomfield used his casting vote to approve it.
Objection speeches were made by Councillor David Nimmo Smith on behalf of Henley Town Council, SODC Councillors for Henley, Gawrysiak, Hillier and Bland, Deidre Wells from Red Kite Consultancy acting on behalf of Mill Lane Residents and Michelle Horsley from Keep Henley Active.
Councillor David Nimmo Smith said, “The Nov 2015 Nortoft report, which is on the application website and was commissioned by this District Council, states on section 18 ‘The loss of the LA Fitness Pool in Henley will have a significant detrimental effect on the local residents, and cannot be suitably mitigated by other pools in the area, due to these pools being at capacity or not being accessible due to cost and/or restrictions of use’. The Nortoft report is not referred to in the Officer report and its conclusions run counter to the report before you. Learning to swim should be available to all, whether old or young, and certainly not in a crowded Gillotts Leisure Centre pool. If this application is approved, then SODC should dip into its substantial reserves and provide the necessary improved facilities themselves. The successful application to register the site as an Asset of Community Value clearly demonstrates the wish of the Henley residents and other users of its local amenity value. This has the backing of the Town Council.”
Deidre Wells from Red Kite Consultancy who was representing the Mill Lane residents spoke about the impact the extra traffic would have on the road which at times is down to one width due to cars parking for the football ground. Deidre said, “There is no proven need for another Care Home, no need at all for an access to Mill Lane apart from the applicants desire to improve the front door to visitors, an unarguable case to protect the rural character of Mill Lane, and a definite need to keep this site available for future business or leisure development to provide facilities Henley really needs. These are sound reasons to refuse this scheme. The applicants, Henthames made a statement at the meeting that “statistics show that Mill Lane could take 1250 cars/hour” which got a huge laugh from the objectors.
Planning Officers had recommended the approval of application as the scheme would provide jobs and care places as well as improving the look of its surroundings. Councillor Paul Harrison, a member of the Planning Committee who voted against said, “I can’t believe the way the SODC Planning Officers are behaving at the moment. SODC are encouraging towns to have Neighbourhood Plans and then they walk all over them.”
Michelle Horsley from Keep Henley Active said afterwards, “The offer letter from the Marlow Club to buy the site should have been discussed. The letter was added to the application 7 days prior to the meeting and should have been reviewed. When one of the Councillors asked me about it, Felix stopped the question and said “it wasn’t relevant.”
Felix Bloomfield said afterwards “I voted in support of this development because the application site is in a sustainable location and this is at the heart of the National Planning Policy Framework. In economic terms the scheme will provide construction jobs, as well as long term expenditure in the local economy, helping to support the on going vibrancy of Henley-On-Thames. It would also generate approximately 70 full time equivalent jobs covering the running of the care home.
In environmental terms the scheme would significantly improve the appearance of the site through good design and landscaping.
The County Highways department did not raise any objection to the development subject to conditions requiring a Construction Traffic Management Plan, a detailed plan of the proposed access to Mill Lane, cycle parking details, an amended travel plan and a surface water drainage scheme.
There are no technical objections to this proposal and outstanding matters can be appropriately dealt with by planning conditions laid out in the case officer’s report. I acknowledge the gym and swimming pool were greatly valued by the local community and their loss is regrettable. However, the Council has no powers to reopen a fitness facility on this site and refusing permission would not have secured its reinstatement. Overall the proposal represents sustainable development, offers a number of benefits and is consistent with the objectives of the NPPF.”




