Petition Launched to Reinstate Full Access to Harpsden Playing Fields

Update from David Brough 23 February:
Following an incident on Sunday 5 February in which local residents were told to get off the playing field in Harpsden, contact was made with a Trustee of the John Hodges Trust. The complaint was passed on to the Trust Chairman, with an initial view that “the tenant of the field is AFC Henley and it is therefore open to them to set the rules for using the field.” A phone conversation with the Trust Chairman confirmed this. After some discussion between AFC Henley and the Trust, on 16 February an email was received from the Trust with the following position: “During the season, locals will be asked to keep off the actual pitch. We believe this is reasonable as AFCH need a decent quality pitch… Signage will be put up to make the access arrangements clear.” At this point a petition was started. The Trust made some movement in position on 18 February, indicating that access would be granted but some areas would be roped off. However, the arrangement would be conditional on the residents’ behaviour and would be revisited should there be a problem. Yesterday, a very clear Press Release was made by the Trust which acknowledged the residents’ use of the field and their right to full access for the whole of the year, accommodating of course training and match times. To conclude, I would like to thank the Trust, together with AFC Henley for clearing up this situation. They are both organisations that carry out valuable work for the community on a voluntary basis and deserve our admiration for the contribution they make. I would also like to thank all those who signed the petition and helped to galvanise support. People can now enjoy the whole field for recreational purposes with their families, friends and dogs throughout the year, as has been the case for decades and as was intended by the Trust founder and is enshrined as one of the main objectives of the Trust.
In a further joint statement from Richard Wilson (chairman of the John Hodges Trust), David Brough and Kirsty Grant, all residents of Harpsden, which was the final post on the petition that is now closed:
Dear All
David, Kirsty and Richard have gone through the whole matter in detail and are delighted to say that we’re all happy with the outcome; we believe the situation is resolved. We’re pleased that the Trust does retain the right to allow inhabitants to access the ground when AFC Henley is not using it, and most importantly that the inhabitants can make use of the field for recreation as John Hodges would have wanted. It’s a wonderful facility for all of us and we just urge everyone who uses it to take good care of it – and particularly the goalmouths! We would also like to thank AFC Henley for providing the small goal for all to use, which is now on the playing field.
David, Kirsty (both residents of Harpsden) & Richard (Chairman of the Trust & resident of Harpsden)
David Brough from Harpsden started a petition last week calling for ‘Reinstate full access to the Harpsden playing field for local residents’.
The petition says “Please sign this petition to urge Richard Wilson, Chairman of the John Hodges Trust For Harpsden Hall, to live up to the Trust’s primary duty and reinstate the use of Harpsden playing field for the local inhabitants. The playing field in Harpsden, at the bottom of Drawback Hill, which has been used by local residents and sports clubs alike for decades, has now become closed to local residents because the Trust has given exclusive access to AFC Henley. Local inhabitants have now been locked out from September to April, except for the small areas outside of the marked up football pitch. A tiny strip.”
The John Hodges’ Trust has responded with the following statement:
“The Trustees of The John Hodges’ Trust for Harpsden Hall fully respect how much the inhabitants of Harpsden and the surrounding neighbourhood value the playing fields. It is a tribute to what John Hodges, the benefactor, wanted to achieve that so much use is made of the ground, especially as he was a believer in the need for facilities for local inhabitants to pursue recreational activities as well as facilities for organised team sports.
There appears to have been a misunderstanding and we want to reassure everyone that the Trust and no other party has the right to set the terms and conditions for access to the Harpsden football ground*.
The Trust believes that inhabitants should have free access to the ground the whole year round when AFC Henley do not have matches, training sessions, or when maintenance is required. The Trust also believes that the Trust, AFC Henley and the local inhabitants should collectively do what we reasonably can to look after the quality of the ground, and particularly the goal mouths.
The Trust believes this approach is the best way to meet John Hodges’ objectives.
* The lease agreement with AFC Henley states: “The Tenant permits the Landlord to use the Football Field and/or the Pavilion for such purposes as the Landlord may require during the months of May to August inclusive and at such other times during the term as it may choose, but in the latter case only during such times as the same are not required by the Tenant for the Permitted Use.” (The Permitted Use means ‘use for the purposes of a football field’.)
Trevor Howell, Chair of AFC has responded by saying:
Recently, while on a circular walk with my wife via Drawback Hill, I saw some children and two dads playing football in one of the goal areas on the Harpsden pitch. After a debate about whether the ground was private I informed them that, although being the Lessee, AFC Henley had no control over access and therefore could not stop them coming into the ground. But I requested that, if they did, would they at least keep out of the goal area, which was already muddy, and play on the other side of the goal away from the playing area. I did not ask them to leave.
“Unfortunately, the text of David Brough’s petition contains several inaccuracies, which I have corrected below. I trust he will have the courtesy to communicate these corrections to those who have been sent a link to the petition, since misinformation can be extremely damaging in a small community like ours.
- Local inhabitants have now been locked out from September to April, except for the small areas outside of the marked up football pitch. A tiny strip. It is not a tiny strip, but adequate space for the kind of games David Brough has been organising. As agreed with the Trust, we have just put a 12’ x 6’ Samba goal there for the families to use if they want to kick a ball around.
- You have to be a boy, you have to be 16-18 years old. Girls are not excluded; they can play if they join the club. The pitch is the only full-sized one we have, so naturally our older teams play there (U16s/17s/18s).
- The signs are about to go up around the field telling you to “KEEP OFF THE PITCH”. We and the Trust have had an informal discussion about whether signage would be helpful and have talked about the need to protect parts of the pitch, but we have not agreed any form of words.
- AFC’s Chairman, Trevor Howell, has already been patrolling the field, ejecting local residents. This is completely untrue. I categorically do not ‘patrol’ the site looking for residents to eject and have never ejected anyone. On one rare occasion I spoke to a dog owner about the risk of faeces getting on the pitch (the dog was off the leash running wild). Residents who regularly jog, train or walk their dogs round the perimeter do so unchallenged.
- AFC themselves have two main sites ……. They are both locked up and unavailable for general recreation, exercise and fun outside of the AFC training and match fixtures. The grass pitches at Jubilee Park are leased to AFC Henley, who are responsible for maintenance and security (costing us c.£15K pa). We allow them to be used by one primary school for PE and two primary schools for their annual sports days. A fitness trainer trains clients on the grass once a week. We consider any reasonable request.
AFC Henley has no desire to prevent anyone from playing football and having fun ̶ that is of course the reason for our existence. However, it is essential that the quality of our pitches is maintained and so we simply ask that common sense prevails in decisions on where to play. On the advice of our professional referees, we are currently limiting the number of games played at Harpsden due to the condition of the pitch.”



