Brakspear Win Rose & Crown Pub Change of Use Appeal
Brakspear have won their appeal for their ‘change of use’ planning application for the Rose & Crown pub in New Street from a public house to residential. The pub ceased trading in 2013.
In 2014 the SODC Planning Committee refused the application because of “the impact on the vitality and viability of Henley town centre and secondly on the character and appearance of the conservation area. The Inspector in her report said, “that extra leisure floor space was needed to support the town centre and these are figures based on a Leisure Needs Assessment study updated in 2010 (before the impact of the recession).” This policy was included in the Oxfordshire 2011 Local Plan.
The Appeals Planning Inspectorate, Simon Hand was provided with an updated version of the same report, the GVA Grimley Leisure Needs Assessment, which was produced to support the emerging local plan. In the appeals decision letter he said, “This presents a rosy picture of the town centre and points out it has a thriving and vibrant drinking and eating culture which is well catered for by chains and independents and this makes an important contribution to its overall vitality and viability. The recommendations for Henley are to provide for a much smaller amount of retail floorspace than was previously thought necessary and no recommendation is made for a specific increase in food and drink floorspace.”
He also said, “I do not consider the loss of the commercial use would harm the character, as in my view it does not contribute to the vitality and viability of the town. New Street, although it remains a very attractive street lined by historic buildings, is clearly not now a part of the vibrant market town character. The use of the building as a dwelling would therefore preserve the character and appearance of the conservation area.”
Brakspear Chief Executive, Tom Davies said, “We are pleased with this decision by the Planning Inspectorate. We are currently taking some time to review the options for the site before making any decision about its future use.”



