Thames Farm Judicial Review Rejected for Second Time by High Court
For the second time, the High Court judge has decided on Tuesday (28 November) that South Oxon District Council (SODC) does not have an arguable case to appeal the Public Inquiry decision for owner of Thames Farm, Claire Engbers to build 95 houses on the site.
The proposed development is for up to 95 dwellings, 40% of which would be affordable houses and associated public open space and landscaping which would include 330 sq metres of allotments, three local play areas and two balancing sustainable ponds.
In August at the Public Inquiry, the Inspector, John Braithwaite appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government stated in his report there were four reasons given for the appeal decision:
Housing Land Supply – The Council accepts that they cannot demonstrate a five years’ supply of housing land so relevant policies for supply of housing are not up to date. The affordable housing across the District is a matter of serious concern. Only 29 affordable units have been delivered in the last 6 years against a need for 50 units per annum.
Character and Appearance of the Area – This landscape type has a mature, well managed and usually well-wood character. This site itself, setting aside tree belts along the north and east boundaries, does not display this character. It is overgrown agricultural land that is neither well managed nor well-wooded. The greatest visual effect of the development would result from the highway works on the A4155. There would be an introduction of a ghost right turn lane, a pedestrian refuge island, another traffic island, the widening of the road to accommodate the right turn lane and other works such as the introduction of footways on both sides of the road.
Highway Safety – The Council (OCC) has not expressed any safety concerns with the the proposed vehicular access into the site or with the new proposed pedestrian refuge island and footpath links to Bolney Lane.
Sustainable Development– There is no evidence, in this regard, to indicate that the proposed development would not benefit the economy of the area. The development would contribute to the supply of market and affordable housing required to meet the needs of present and future generations and there is no reason to suppose that the scheme, the design of which would be developed at reserved matters stage, would not be a high quality built environment.
Paul Harrison, District Councillor said, “SODC Leader, John Cotton has told Councillors they are seriously considering going for a full Judicial Review.”
A spokesperson for SODC said, “We have seven days to lodge an appeal and are currently considering whether or not we will do this.”



