SODC to Continue to Appeal Thames Farm Decision
South Oxfordshire District Council have announced that they will continue their fight to oppose the decision for 95 houses to be built on Thames Farm on the Reading Road and will appealing to the Court of Appeal.
Last week the Council lost a second appeal for a judicial review by the High Court. The judge ruled for the second time that they did not have an arguable case to appeal the Public Inquiry decision made by the Planning Inspectorate in August this year.
The site which is owned by Claire Engbers has been through a number of planning applications and appeals. The first application for 110 houses was submitted in July 2013 and was refused with a subsequent appeal which went to a Public Inquiry which was finally dismissed in May 2015. A challenge to the dismissal of the appeal was brought to the High Court and was successful. It said that the Planning Inspector’s approach to highway matters was incorrect. The decision of the High Court was challenged but was upheld in the Court of Appeal. The new application for 95 houses was submitted in March 2016 and in September 2016 SODC Planning Committee unanimously refused the application. The site was not included in the Henley & Harpsden Neighbourhood plan.
Paul Harrison, District Councillor for Shiplake said, “I know the majority of residents in Shiplake will be grateful that SODC have decided to challenge the decision of the Inspectorate by going for a full judicial review. This decision won’t have been taken likely as the costs can be high but when you consider the investment by towns and villages in neighbourhood plans throughout the district will be over £500,000, these could be invalidated if the decision of the Inspectorate was allowed to stand.”
John Howell, Henley MP has said, “The Planning Inspector came to the conclusion that SODC did not even have a 3 year housing land supply. As the site is in the area covered by the Henley and Harpsden Joint Neighbourhood Plan (HHJNP) this judgement and its divergence from the recognised figure is important as it seemingly undermines the HHJNP. Hence the challenge to the Planning Inspector’s decision.
Since the time of the Thames Farm decision, there have been two other appeals heard by two different Planning Inspectors and each has concluded that SODC does have a 4.1 year housing land supply.
Hence there is concern over the inconsistency of the decisions made by different Planning Inspectors. This is rightly being challenged through the legal system by SODC. I have also raised it with the Secretary of State and the Chief Planning Officer and in other ways. Both are taking these concerns seriously and investigating on a wider basis.”




