Townlands Steering Group Asking Sue Ryder for Data to Support Decrease in Demand
The Townlands Steering Group (TSG) is asking Sue Ryder to provide data to support their statement announcing that the Joyce Grove hospice is to close on 31 March due to decrease in demand.
The statement from Sue Ryder said, “After careful investigation with referral partners, the charity feels assured that the decline in patient numbers is due to a decrease in demand.”
The TSG would like Sue Ryder to provide the following data used to support this assessment:
- What is the assessed demand for In Patient Beds in South Oxon?
- Is the reported decline merely a response to the reduction in provision at Joyce Grove in the last 18 months from 12 to 4?
- How many patients have been unable to be admitted to Joyce Grove due to lack of available beds?
- Where did these patients end up?
- How many of these patients became reluctant users of the Hospice at Home Service?
- How many patients ended up as Delayed Transfers of Care (DTOC aka bed blockers) from acute beds such as those at Royal Berks?
- Why has the previously assessed demand of 8 beds been superseded?
The charity also referred to a recent survey of the general public, with over 70% of respondents stating that they would prefer to die at home. They said, “Sue Ryder continues to see demand increase for its Hospice at Home service in South Oxfordshire. Hospice at Home service now in its second year, has so far supported 539 patients.” The TSG would like to see the Terms of Reference of the survey and they question whether the survey does reflect public opinion because how were the 30% of 539. i.e. 161 patients who would appear to prefer inpatient care provided with the inpatient care they needed? The TSG have calculated that this number is similar to the 8 beds @ 3 weeks stay leading to an assessed need of 138 patients per annum provided by Sue Ryder to the community in Aug 2018.
Sue Ryder stated the charity “knows that inpatient care in a hospice setting remains the right choice for some patients […] the charity will continue to work closely with other local providers who are already delivering inpatient care.” The TSG want to know about this inpatient care, how it is to be provided, by whom, and where. They would like to know the availability of beds at the Duchess of Kent Hospice in Reading as they have offered beds for patients there as they understand that the hospice is only partially open due to staff shortages and has no spare capacity.
Chair of the TSG Councillor Ian Reismann said, “The TSG and others are in receipt of many expressions of concern across the community on the lack of transparency regarding the closure of this important and respected service. We have approached Sue Ryder and requested that they engage with the community to answer the questions raised here. We accept that a clear plan with supporting evidence may be emerging behind the scenes, and when Sue Ryder (and other stakeholders such as the CCG) are able to share this information, the community will feel much more positive about the proposed changes. Unfortunately Sue Ryder have declined to meet with us or other community representatives to provide reassurances on the continuity of services to a very vulnerable sector of the community. We have been offered a meeting in April, but by then the existing service will have closed. The community and TSG are strong supporters of the services provided by Sue Ryder, and recognise the challenges faced in maintaining the current level of service and the difficulty in taking these decisions.”
Sarah Brody, Head of PR for Sue Ryder said, “We have provided detailed statements in the last few weeks regarding our plans to close the inpatient unit at the end of March, the circumstances that led us to that decision, where inpatient care will continue to be provided and our search for a new location to act as a hub for the rest of our services, which will all be continuing.”
“We are aware that Mr Reissmann has additional questions and we have explained to him that we will be happy to address them, hopefully alongside the CCG so that together we can provide full and detailed answers to him.”
“In the immediate term however we must focus on supporting our patients and staff during this period of transition for the service.”




