New Outbuilding on Same Spot & Smaller is Reported to SODC Planning
Claudia Rowberry who lives in a cottage with a small paddock attached in a private road off the Reading Road replaced an old stable-like building in February 2020 and replaced it with a new shed in March 2020. In November she received an unannounced visit from a SODC Planning Officer to investigate a complaint about the erection of the outbuilding which she said was in breach of planning control.
Claudia said, “It was quite a shock and pretty upsetting at the time to have a visit from an SODC planning enforcement officer calling at my home unannounced especially during the pandemic whilst I was also alone as my son Mark was in Devon. Her opening words you have been reported for putting up a shed without planning permission. I did explain that it was a replacement and the new shed was smaller and lower to the previous one which as you can see from the photos above was derelict and dangerous but to no avail I have to apply for planning permission.”
Julie Perrin, the SODC Planning Officer sent an email saying, “To resolve the breach of planning control your mother may remove the outbuilding, alternatively she may wish to consider submitting a retrospective planning application seeking permission to retain the structure as built. Please note that presenting this as an option does not imply that permission will be granted, all applications are considered on their own merits.” She has given a deadline of 16 January 2021 to submit a retrospective planning application.
The new building cost £6,000 including materials and labour.
Henley Mayor, Councillor Ken Arlett has replied to Claudia’s son, Mark saying, “I suppose Julie is working to the letter of the law, but would in this case question if what has been done does affect anyone, that would be my first question. Myself if it is shown that it is a like for like then is there any damage, answer is probably no. So perhaps try and work on that basis. What you do not want is an enforcement notice – that does no one any good. In my years as a Councillor I have always tried to use the ‘common sense’ approach so hopefully this will work.”
The paddock land is in the parish of Harpsden. Chair of Harpsden Parish Council, Kester George declined to comment on the breach.
Claudia and Mark said, “The Council won’t tell us who reported this but we have our suspicions. It is a genuine mistake as the new building is in exactly the same spot, slightly smaller and slightly less in height than the old one.”
A spokesperson for SODC said, “Our officers are working with the landowner and their planning agent to resolve the breach of planning control in accordance with our normal practice and procedures. The new building needs planning permission because it is a residential shed on agricultural land.”




