Official Statement on Proposal for Health Services at New Townlands Hospital
Statement from Councillor Ian Reissman, Chair of Townlands Steering Group
Everyone was delighted when the Business Case for the Townlands redevelopment was approved. We were equally happy when Planning permission was granted, and then the contract was signed with Amber Infrastructure and development finally started.
Achieving this result has taken many years, and there were many twists and turns, and it appears there is now another as the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) is reviewing the health services that are to be provided in our new hospital. Of course we all thought this had been decided long ago. However it is important to remember that the hospital is being built, and it is as certain as it can be that the new hospital will be opened in the next year providing a range of services that we need.
The question is: What is still to be decided?
We know that Sue Ryder are no longer planning to to move into the top floor. (Although a final decision has yet to be made). The CCG want to put forward a new model of care in which bedded care (i,e, the 18 bed Peppard Ward) is replaced by
– 5 Emergency Multi Disciplinary Unit (EMU) beds leased from the Care Home
– A new set of services such as Dialysis etc
The intention is to change the way the health needs currently being met by the Peppard Ward beds, to a model in which care is either provided in the home, or by more rapid access to long term institutional care. The questions we need to consider are:
– Is this a better model of care?
– Can the new model be set up in time for the opening of the new hospital?
We have asked the GPs who believe that such a model has the following potential gains for health/social care provision
- many patients prefer to be cared for in their homes
- an increased range of services can be provided on the site removing the need for many patients to travel to Royal Berks, John Radcliffe etc.
However there are number of potential downsides and uncertainties:
- There is widespread concern regarding the ability of Adult Social Services to deliver the home care safely and with dignity.
- There have been many similar moves to a more home based model in the past which have had limited success. At a time of austerity, with perhaps worse to come, can Oxfordshire County Council (OCC) really commit to providing the resources necessary?
- Even if OCC are able to this, will they be able to present a cogent plan on 11 May which the community accept as deliverable?
It is clear from anecdotal evidence as well as the considered view of GPs, that there is a real need which cannot be met in this way. The only way to provide the sort of step up/step down care which is needed is using beds so that people who need hospital care when recovering can do this outside an expensive and distant acute bed.
The CCG have agreed a consultation to start on May 11 for four weeks. They are committed to providing a detailed description of the Service Model on which to consult. It is far from clear that this is possible and there must be great concern that there will be insufficient detail to allay the concerns of the community – particularly on the Adult Social Services.
There has also been the distraction of the suggestion that this is a numbers game and the change of plan is a simple dilution of 18 to 5 beds. This is much too simplistic a way to look at the situation. The options which may be proposed on May 11 will include a number of new and different services which may be possible on the site. The options will also need to include detailed and complex descriptions of the supporting systems that will be put in place to ensure the new model to support the EMU beds (i.e. home care and more care homes places). Consideration of these and their credibility will need a great deal of thought and analysis. It is very important we do not make hasty decisions on the proposals until we see much more detail and have had the opportunity to listen the voices of those who have the most knowledge and trust : our GPs.
The community has a long record of considering the health services and Townlands in a mature and thoughtful way. It would be highly damaging to Townlands and our health services if a hasty and ill-considered response were to be made before all the facts are available. It would also be damaging if the community were to fail to act cohesively or to be driven by motives other than seeking the best deal possible for the new hospital.
We have come so far in the last ten years by thoughtful analysis, listening and speaking clearly to the decision makers using the authority of the Townlands Steering Group and this is how we should continue.
Cllr Ian Reissmann
Chair of Townlands Steering Group




could you tell me if there will be more clinics and follower on visit to consultants to be held at this hosp. it is not fair we the people have to go to all these other hosp for a five minute appointment I myself have always told we hope to get a clinic here but never do it seems to me its just going to be old peoples home with a few beds for others what was wrong with chilterns end I worked there for 28 years even when it was updated so why a new one lets have a hosp that’s for everyone in this area