TSG Dismayed That CCG to Press on With Unpopular Proposals for Townlands
The Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) have announced that they are to push forward their proposals to Phase 2. The CCG plan would mean that the 18 beds originally planned for the new Townlands Hospital are not re-provided as originally promised in the Full Business Case in 2012.
The plans were the subject of a consultation which closed on 15 June and met with near universal rejection at a series of meetings at which the CCG presented the proposals. The CCG sent this message yesterday to all respondents who completed the survey.
“It is difficult to see how the community could have rejected these proposals more firmly. It was clear to anyone who read the paperwork and listened to the presentations, that there was no clear plan in place to implement the new proposals. No additional resources for Adult Social Care or Community Health Care were identified”, said Townlands Steering Group Leader Councillor Ian Reissmann. “Indeed the CCG told us they would not be providing any additional Adult Social Care or Community Health Care to support their plans. This must place patient care at risk, and the community have made abundantly clear that this must not happen”, he continued.
There are widespread concerns over the slanted questionnaire which made it difficult to explicitly oppose the plans. “The CCG are claiming the responses are in favour of the principle of a RACU (Rapid Access Care Unit). This question was never asked – we were asked about the principle of Home Care. Towards the end of the consultation we were suddenly told this was to be a 3 day RACU service. The community feels that the CCG has not been honest with us,” said Councillor Reissmann.
The debate on the RACU was central to many contributions from the community at the TSG meeting held on 9 June 9. Many GPs made clear their opposition to the CCG proposals. Dr Chris Langley (from the Bell Surgery) and Dr Phil Unwin were unequivocal: they supported the TSG’s position that the beds must be part of the new hospital when it opens in November 2015. “The GPs support for the beds going into the new hospital fatally undermines the CCGs case. The GPs need to use the system every day to make sure their patients receive the care they need. The CCG are supposed to be a clinicians group – why are they ignoring the most informed and most directly involved clinicians? The CCG’s claim that they are working with the Henley GPs is misleading at best.” asked Councillor Reissmann.
The TSG deny they are not in favour of progress. “We will listen to CCG plans which are comprehensive, detailed, costed and include a clear transition plan which will be monitored and scrutinised. What we have now is nothing like that. We cannot have any confidence that the proposals can be planned and implemented in four months. “As the CCG have clearly stopped listening to the community, we have no choice but to step up the campaign to be as vocal and high profile as possible. A centrepiece of the campaign will be a march in Henley at the end of July (date to be confirmed). I urge everyone to take part and support the TSG’s campaign in opposing the CCG plans, said Councillor Reissman.”


The consultation was a farce – virtually no valid information other than platitudes provided in consultation document; dishonesty throughout from CCG (examples – using EMU examples to justify case whereas Townlands will get lesser RACU; it having to be dragged out in questioning that the RACU is only three days a week/limited hours); late delivered “model” on bed usage proves the decision was made ahead of looking at evidence, and was immediately shown to be flawed in a number of important respects – for instance no provision for population growth/demographics; consultation questionnaire deliberately biased not to invite answers on beds – which was the key subject of the consultation; claiming to have “consulted” while 100% ignoring the results of said Consultation.
Henley and the surrounding parishes which are a huge part of the Townlands user group must unite to fight this cynical charade and retain a bedded unit of right size & resourcing.