Decision on Townlands to be Postponed
The Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) has published its paper on Townlands Hospital for the Board of the CCG. As a result of representations by John Howell MP, it recommends that a final decision is postponed on the hospital until full assurance can be provided on a number of arrangements including the ambulatory care model and the number of beds. In other words, the report recommends further engagement with stakeholders in developing the responses to these issues, in order that the Board can take a decision.
The report shows major changes to the model being proposed by the CCG. These include:
(1) Deferring a final decision on the hospital pending further engagement;
(2) The RACU will now be open and available for 7 days a week rather than the 3 days proposed;
(3) Further discussion and engagement on the ambulatory care model and the number of beds;
(4) A firmer transition plan.
David Nimmo Smith said, “The CCG option 3, which their Board is recommended to approve on Thursday, starts off “To endorse the clinical model proposed …..” which to me implies that they will continue with their current direction of travel, as outlined in the consultation meetings and that they will further consult with the Community – by fleshing out transition details, staffing arrangements etc – on their existing model. In view of the expressions expressed to date, I think it unlikely that the Community will buy that. In the meantime, they are unlikely to stop work on the site as the Contractor will submit claims for being stopped, disruptive working etc. I am aware of the dilemma that the CCG finds itself in. There is much that is good and welcomed in the facilities to be provided. MIU, more consultants, day care etc. An increasing outreach from the Royal Berks in Reading. The model of care being proposed may be the correct direction of travel, but the Henley and District community – all 90,000 – have not bought into it.”
John Howell said:
“To quote Sir Winston Churchill ‘to jaw-jaw is always better than to war-war’. That is precisely what I have been doing with the CCG and the result is that it has taken on board many of the points I have made. The future of the hospital is not an academic exercise it is about our health and well-being and even about saving lives. The services which will be provided are likely to be best placed to do this and I welcome the CCG’s inclusion of my comments.
“They have not gone ahead with a final recommendation about the hospital. That is the subject of continuing discussion and engagement with stakeholders. It would be helpful if people would return to looking at the site as the provision of a ‘health campus’ – a phrase used by everyone before the rebuild. There is provision of beds on site. The issue of whether they are in the hospital or in the care home is not the main point. The main point is that I would like to see confirmation of what the term ‘flexible’ means in describing the number of beds available and exactly how many this will include.
“I am also concerned, as I always have been, that the staffing of the ambulatory care model is not secure enough and that further engagement is required here. This would be materially improved if adult social care services and the services provided by the NHS were under one roof. I shall continue to use parliamentary means, particularly in the Cities and Local Government Devolution Bill, to provide the County Council and the NHS with the opportunity for this to happen.”
John will be writing to the Board with his comments. He will not be attending the Board meeting as he has an official, parliamentary trip abroad at the time.
We are awaiting a quote from Ian Reissman, Chair of the Townlands Steering Group who left for holiday today.




John Howell’s quote “The issue of whether they are in the hospital or in the care home is not the main point.” shows that he doesn’t understand one of the main difficulties with the plan. It is vitally important that beds are available with the patients being looked after by fully qualified health staff. It is unfair on care home staff to have to provide patient care which is outside their capabilities.
Is it not possible to keep politics out of the debate about Townlands ? The community is united in wanting beds. The main point is absolutely whether the beds are hospital beds or care home beds. Henley needs hospital beds. It is a pity John Howell MP has not engaged in debate with his constituents, and sought to persuade them of the rightness of his view.
What is the purpose of the remark about Ian Reissmann ? If it was possible to get quotes from John Howell MP before he went off, why did no one get a quote from the Chairman of the Townsland Steering group ?
This reads more like a Conservative Party press release than a piece of journalism.
We are still waiting for a quote from the Townlands Steering Group. We’ve added a quote now from David Nimmo Smith Henley’s County Councillor. If you can help with getting a quote from Councillor Gawrysiak that would be appreciated as I requested it yesterday.