Big Clash at Council Meeting Over Proposed Sub Lease to Physiolistic at Rugby Club
Physiolistic, a physiotherapy clinic, who are currently based on the proposed Neighbourhood Planning housing development site at the top of Greys Road, behind the shops, has been granted planning application by SODC to build a new clinic at Henley Rugby Club. The application submitted is to demolish existing timber storage shed and construct a new clinic for physiotherapy uses (Class 01), together with new car parking bays and associated hard and soft landscaping.
The rugby club ground is owned by Henley Town Council and therefore their agreement is now required for sub leasing.
At the Finance, Strategy and Management Meeting on Tuesday, the sub leasing was discussed. The Mayor, Councillor Brookes proposed that this was approved at the meeting and said that Oxfordshire County Council’s solicitors had confirmed that sub leasing was allowed. A source told us that the Mayor had been having secret meetings to discuss this issue and was trying to push this through without the knowledge of all the councillors. Councillor Ian Reissmann requested that all the councillors needed to see this advice and the instructions given. He proposed along with Councillor Hillier a special Full Council Meeting next Tuesday (27 September) to consider the advice so that the Council could make an informed decision to agree this as Physiolistic could not wait 3 weeks for this to be ratified at Full Council on 11 October.
At this point Councillor Dylan Thomas, got very irate and claimed that “HRG were trying to kill jobs and livelihoods in town.” When the vote took place, Councillor Nimmo Smith abstained and Councillor Thomas voted against and then stormed out, saying the meeting was a “disgrace.”
Afterwards Councillor Reissmann and Hillier made the following statement: “We proposed and seconded a proposal that, while agreeing with the proposal in principle, allowed us to be sure that the arrangement legally protected the Town Council (HTC) and the town’s assets as well as the Rugby Club and Physiolistic. We had previously been told that HTC’s lease to the Rugby did not allow sub leasing. We felt that it was important to make sure we had read and understood the changed advice from our solicitors. This was not available. We felt this was legal, proper and prudent. Other Councillors from both parties supported our proposal which was voted through. This combination of practicality and propriety seems very sensible and we are glad the committee agreed. In any case the FS&M committee did not have the power to approve the proposal which would (without our proposal) have had to wait until Oct 11th. Therefore our proposal actually speeded up the Town Council’s decision.”
The Mayor, Councillor Brookes said afterwards, “We are having a Special Full Council on Tuesday, 7pm in the Fire Station Gallery to approve the Physiolistic sub lease in principle. Whilst the Rugby Club have to seek Henley Town Council’s (HTC) permission to sub lease, HTC would not be permitted to withhold consent so it should be a formality.”





I think you should point out that Cllr Nimmo Smith is a member of the Rugby Club and took no part in the discussion or the voting. His membership was declared at the start of the meeting. He did not abstain. It is unfortunate that the Solicitor advice was received by the Town Council on 2 August but had not been forwarded to all Councillors.
Please amend your article.
I’m compelled to comment because this article is inaccurate and misleading. Firstly there was nobody from the Herald at the FSM meeting so all of this is second hand and clearly written with an Anti-Conservative bias and with little regard for the facts. Secondly, I (Cllr Dylan Thomas) did not ‘storm out after the vote on the Rugby club sub lease’. So kindly correct this false accusation.
Due to Cllrs Reissmann’s verbose grandstanding and politicking the FSM meeting unnecessarily went on past 10pm at which point according to standing orders a vote must taken to agree to continue with the agenda past 10pm. I voted against continuing the meeting and left because with new born twins I have family responsibilities. I then wished everyone good evening before leaving although I did reiterate my displeasure with the vote and the potential impact the unnecessary delays could have on a local business and local jobs.
We don’t attend Council meetings. We were told about your behaviour from a number of Councillors who attended the meeting.