Thames Farm Owner Wins Her Appeal for Housing Development
Claire Engbers has won her appeal to build 95 dwellings on Thames Farm on the Reading Road in Shiplake.
The Planning Inspectorate’s decision was announced today after a three day hearing which took place at Nettlebed Village Hall in June.
The site has been through a number of planning applications and appeals. The first application for 110 houses was submitted in July 2013 and was refused with a subsequent appeal which went to a Public Inquiry which was finally dismissed in May 2015. A challenge to the dismissal of the appeal was brought to the High Court and was successful. The decision of the High Court was challenged but was upheld in the court of Appeal. The new application for 95 houses was submitted in March 2016 and in September 2016 SODC Planning Committee unanimously refused the application. The site was not included in the Henley & Harpsden Neighbourhood plan.
The proposed development is for up to 95 dwellings, 40% of which would be affordable houses and associated public open space and landscaping which would include 330 sq metres of allotments, three local play areas and two balancing sustainable ponds.
The Inspector, John Braithwaite appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government stated in his report there were four reasons given for the appeal decision:
Housing Land Supply – The Council accepts that they cannot demonstrate a five years’ supply of housing land so relevant policies for supply of housing are not up to date. The affordable housing across the District is a matter of serious concern. Only 29 affordable units have been delivered in the last 6 years against a need for 50 units per annum.
Character and Appearance of the Area – This landscape type has a mature, well managed and usually well-wood character. This site itself, setting aside tree belts along the north and east boundaries, does not display this character. It is overgrown agricultural land that is neither well managed nor well-wooded. The greatest visual effect of the development would result from the highway works on the A4155. There would be an introduction of a ghost right turn lane, a pedestrian refuge island, another traffic island, the widening of the road to accommodate the right turn lane and other works such as the introduction of footways on both sides of the road.
Highway Safety – The Council (OCC) has not expressed any safety concerns with the the proposed vehicular access into the site or with the new proposed pedestrian refuge island and footpath links to Bolney Lane.
Sustainable Development– There is no evidence, in this regard, to indicate that the proposed development would not benefit the economy of the area. The development would contribute to the supply of market and affordable housing required to meet the needs of present and future generations and there is no reason to suppose that the scheme, the design of which would be developed at reserved matters stage, would not be a high quality built environment.
You can read the full Planning Inspectorate decision report here.
Cllr Stefan Gawrysiak said “ I am totally shocked by this decision. The most worrying thing is that Conservative controlled SODC do not even have a 3 year land supply which would protect our Neighbourhood Plan. This drives a coach and horses through the Plan which means that Henley is open season for developers. SODC must appeal this decision in the High Court because all Neighbourhood Plans are in jeopardy in South Oxfordshire. This is not Henley’s mess, we in good faith developed our NP and it is SODC who has let us down. SODC should refund to Henley the £100,000 spent on our plan.”
Councillor Julian Brookes on behalf of the Henley Town Council Conservative Councillor Group said:
“We were very surprised at the Planning Inspector’s decision and fully support the statement issued by our MP.
http://www.johnhowellmp.com/news/thames-farm-planning-appeal-decision/1047
Henley and Harpsden joined together to produce a neighbourhood plan to provide for the housing which the NPPF and SODC’s Local Plan called for. That number was increased by 25 % by the time the plan was made. We now find that the NPPF has so many significant loopholes that not only is major development taking place beyond those defined in the neighbourhood plan but has also previously enabled the removal of the provision of the 40% of affordable dwellings.
We must lobby every level of Government to remove the loopholes so that the NPPF, Local Plans and Neighbourhood Plans achieve the intended twin objectives of empowering the local community and providing the dwellings and affordable homes in the timeframe and quantity required. In the meantime, we will work closely with our LPA to ensure that all applications are approved with the 40% affordable element except where current legislation specifically provides otherwise.
I call on our neighbour, the Housing Minister and MP for Reading West, Alok Sharma to remove the loopholes in the NPPF as a matter of urgency to provide the right atmosphere and legislative infrastructure which will enable the provision of much needed housing in a clear and fair manner removing the loopholes of care homes (C2 etc), viability, permitted development rights and land banking in the latter case by giving LPAs the power to conduct compulsory purchase to release horded building land.”





Nowhere in this article above, nor in the article in the Henley newspaper do I read anything about extra school places to accommodate 95 homes worth of children nor do I read anything about any additional doctors and other medical staff to look after 95 homes worth of people. Is all this support supposed to materialise out of thin air????
Henley has not been able to attract key workers for there is nowhere for them to live!
There are huge economic benefits to having housing of all sorts, including housing which supports key-workers and lower-income families who are well placed to service communities!
Our *****-LIKE MP has done well to secure funding for schools and other projects and should it be deemed necessary more will be sought
We do not want to turn Henley and its surrounding villages into a closed area where we will be left behind – let the place be vibrant and establish real communities for the long term and a place where my children can aspire to remain!
Claire is a model citizien – a modern day Erin Brokovitch – a tough fight against the system to achieve what is right. Our community is starved of affordble homes and she is a leader.
David won against Goliath and Claire has won against the ‘visibly corrupt’ SODC and the wealthy NIMBYs trying to block all
Well done Claire – we need more of you.