Make Henley Shine Responds to EA’s Objections on Bridge Lights Application
Gavin Jackson, the architect on the Make Henley Shine bridge lights working group has written a letter to Sarah Green at the Environment Agency responding to her objections raised against the planning application.
In the open letter he said, “I would like to refer you to: our application to see the various supporting environmental and ecological reports along with evidence which demonstrate the highly considered rationale for the installation. Also, the application and reports specifically respond to your concerns about navigation and biodiversity.
The bridge already has street lights on it at each end, and is also very well lit by the adjacent buildings (Henley Royal Regatta, Angel on the Bridge pub, The Relais hotel, St Mary’s church and the promenade path lighting). Also, it was lit by festoon lights in the 1900s, and more recently by floodlights in the 1970’s, so there is a precedent for such installations on Henley bridge.
Directly responding to your two reasons to object:
1. Unacceptable impact to the river Thames Navigation
Please read the 55 page supporting report and evidence from SKR Lighting Design, which specifically highlights that the bridge is under Local Planning Authorities criteria for exterior lighting control and is judged to be in an E3/4 Environmental Zone. This means it is in a Suburban/Urban medium to high district brightness for a well inhabited urban settlement and town centre with high levels of night-time activity.
The report includes the following:
- A survey of the bridge and surrounding areas, including all the existing installed exterior lighting, previous scheme floodlighting, local authority street lighting and neighbouring building lighting.
- Day, dusk and night photo survey.
- Light level readings at night, 1 hour after dusk.
- The surrounding roads, and neighbouring buildings of note.
- 3D calculation study of the proposed lighting for Henley bridge.
- Industry standard DIALUX EVO software is used for lighting calculations.
- Reflectance values are used and are appropriate for the materials and surfaces encountered.
- Luminaires used were those that we can rely on for accurate photometric data and technical support. In this case Signify Lighting UK.
- Recommendations for future design and construction tender.
- Specification and controls information.
- Commissioning and programming.
The information within the report is collated to convey a positive lighting design proposal for this historic bridge, within a sensitive and beautiful part of the River Thames. The bridge illumination proposed is sustainable, low energy LED. It is a restrained scheme that will gently highlight the features of the architecture, while balancing with the sensitivities of the immediate ecological river setting and sensitive fabric of the structure.
Also, this solution is a significant improvement on the previous floodlighting scheme in the 1970’s and would use one third of the energy and emit only 15% of the light of the old scheme. However, for this scheme to be a success, the report includes a detailed analysis of the surrounding illuminated townscape. In its current state the footprint of lighting in the area already contributes and spoils the setting with significant uncontrolled light pollution from commercial, domestic and continuous stream of car headlights on and around the bridge. To add to the success of the scheme, several surrounding lighting elements would benefit from simple improvement, therefore contributing to the improved look of the bridge, as well as improving the ecological situation in this part of the River Thames.
Therefore, vessels navigating the river around the bridge would benefit from the additional gentle lighting of the bridge area with respect to their night vision. This would help vessels avoid previous crashes into the historic bridge as a result of a lack of adequate lighting. Also, the broader scheme itself aims to reduce overall lighting in the vicinity of the bridge.
Jonathan Hobbs, Chairman of the Passenger Boat Association and Managing Director of Hobbs Boats of Henley, whose family has been running commercial and tourist boating in Henley for over 150 years, and has the largest fleet of boats anywhere on the Thames, has been publicly very vocal in supporting the proposed lighting installation because: “It would create more interest in off-season boat trips and ultimately benefit the night-time economy of Henley with visitors from river trips, eating and drinking in the town before and after trips. It would also enormously improve the safety of night-time navigation for many river users.”
2. Unacceptable impact on biodiversity
In your letter to SODC, you state that our application is not supported by a bat survey or takes into account of the potential on bats as a result of the proposal. Please read the 58 page Ecological Appraisal, Roost Assessment and Bat Surveys from Thomson Environmental Consultants, an independent ecology agency. They were commissioned to undertake a Preliminary Ecological Appraisal, a Preliminary Roost Assessment (PRA) and a bat activity survey accompanied by static monitoring surveys of Henley bridge. The survey information was used as supporting information for compliance with relevant legislation and planning policies.
Thomson Environmental Consultants, in October 2022, after discussion with South Oxfordshire District Council included their recommendations regarding the bat surveys as well as other wildlife.
The report concluded that the proposed development is unlikely to have a negative impact on statutory sites, non-statutory sites, ancient woodland or priority habitats due to the sufficient distance from the site and the small scale of the proposed works.
The report also showed that no bats, or evidence of bats were found during the PRA of the bridge. The Henley bridge was assessed to have negligible potential to support roosting bats. However, the connectivity to the surrounding area is considered moderate, with a number of valuable greenspaces nearby which may support bats in term of providing foraging habitat and roosting opportunities.
The proposed lighting scheme has taken into consideration the recommendations from the Thomson Report and specifically concerning bats to comply with best practice guidance (Collins (Ed. 2016), any lighting along the River Thames should be installed sensitively for bats. We also took into account the Bat Conservation Trust’s ‘Recommendations to help minimise the impact of artificial lighting’ and the Institution of Lighting Professionals ‘Guidance Notes for the Reduction of Obstructive Light’
- Excessive lighting and the spread of light has been minimised
- Turning off the lights from midnight when bats are foraging or commuting
- Only low energy Light Emitting Diodes (LEDs) will be used
- Reflective surfaces beneath the lighting will be avoided
- Lights with ultraviolet components will be avoided
- Warm-white long wavelength lights will be used
The report concluded that the lighting design already includes some features which could be of benefit to bats, as Henley bridge and surrounding areas are currently illuminated at night, the bridge levels will be lesser than the surrounding area.
So, in conclusion. We have made a thorough and considered approach to the proposed application, with substantive supporting evidence from highly qualified independent organisations, to negate the various issues you’ve highlighted and in turn do not accept your reasons for opposing the application.”
The application is due to be reviewed by South Oxfordshire District Council in January – the date is still to be confirmed. Chair of the Make Henley Shine working group, Daniel Bausor said, “If you support Make Henley Shine – and especially if you are a boat owner/river user, please do email your views to: enquiries_THM@environment-agency.gov.uk and cc South Oxfordshire District Council Planning: enquiries@southoxon.gov.uk including Planning REF: P23/S3194/FUL in the Subject line.”









Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!