Council’s Free Christmas Trees Sparks Controversy as Retailers Question Fairness
At the Full Council Meeting on Tuesday evening, the decision by the Council to provide free Christmas trees again this year to businesses in the centre of town was challenged by retailers and Councillor David Eggleton was stopped by the Mayor in asking his questions in the public participation.
Lorraine Hillier owner of Hot Gossip on Reading Road said, “Why were free Christmas trees given to businesses in Duke Street, Market Place, Bell Street (top of) and Hart Street and even put on empty shops and multi-nationals. Is this a two-tier system in operation whereby those outside the magic circle are less worthy? We used to have a level playing field when we all paid for our own trees. Are free Christmas trees being given again this year free to the top tier? I received an email from the Council suggesting that I encourage businesses in Reading Road to organise trees through Windowflowers. We want the public to know that we have not excluded ourselves from the festivities. The trees are a divisive initiative in our market town. The town should be united in celebrating the spirit of Christmas and not divided.”
Town Clerk, Sheridan Jacklin-Edwards responded by saying, “The Council agreed in January 2023 after such a poor showing in Christmas 2022 that we would look to overhaul the whole light display for the benefit of the town so we invested in new brackets and infrastructure around the town so that we would make sure there was a good light display. Previously businesses had to buy their own trees and we were at the mercy as to which businesses bought them and how good the town centre would look. It was therefore decided the focus of the display would in the centre of town and we identified 150 premises where we could put up our own trees to complement the festive lighting. It was a huge investment on the part of the Council, and it is an ongoing investment which we are paying for through sponsorship. The cut off was decided where we have the wiring in the town centre and where we can control the electrical infrastructure. Outside of that we are at the mercy of private residents and businesses and their electrical supply. If we extended it down Northfield End, New Street, Thameside, Reading Road etc it would probably be another £15K and we just don’t have the budget.”
Lorraine corrected the Town Clerk by confirming that when she had a tree before it was put on the Town Council grid, and she still had the bracket.
Eva Rickett from Henley Scan spoke on behalf of Sue Turner, Candela Hypnosis as she was in hospital. She said, “Sue really feels that it looks mean on her when she has customers coming and there are trees up and there isn’t a sign that says what the Town Council do, and this looks like she is a stingy person. I agree with Lorraine about the divisiveness. It would nice, although probably too late for this year, to consider what is the solution. It will benefit everybody; the more trees we have the more people will come in. Can we have a solution with a little extra cost? The small shops are the destination shops for the town. The size of the shop, location or whether you have a non-shop doesn’t always show what we bring into town.”
Henley Mayor, Councillor Rory Hunt who was chairing the meeting said that the Town Clerk has given his detailed response so we’re going to move on from the Christmas trees. Councillor David Eggleton asked if he could raise some questions in the public participation and was told no and he had the discretion to do this. David said, “I’ve got a right to speak on that. Even though there are two other people I’ve got the right to speak. After the Mayor responded, David replied, “That just sums it all up really.” He then left the meeting. The Public participation in the agenda allows the public to speak for up to 3 minutes each and up to 20 minutes for the meeting. This agenda item lasted 9 mins 40 secs.
We asked Councillor Eggleton afterwards what he wanted to say. He said, “I wanted to ask what the cost of the infrastructure for the Christmas lights has cost over the last few years to the taxpayer as if I remember we spent £30K just a few years ago. I see that we are going to be spending another £20K this year. I also wanted to find out what the Council had done about obtaining the lights and brackets that the last contractor was asked to return and whether they did. And how are the Council managing the brackets on premises they don’t own, and did they get correct permission as some of the premises are listed buildings?”
The Council has raised £17K in sponsorship for the Christmas initiatives this year compared to £25K last year.







Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!