Developer Appeals Against Refusal of Planning for Revision on Newtown Road Houses
Knole Homes are appealing South Oxfordshire District Councils decision to refuse the variation of their plans for four dwellings at the entrance to Newtown Road.
An original planning application was approved in April 2024 for the four dwellings. The developers now want to make use of attic space in plots 2, 3 and 4, reduce plot 2’s study size and replace the front dormer window in plot 4 with a rooflight.
SODC refused the planning application on 3 conditions. They said “The proposed development would have a significantly increased bulk and massing compared with the extant planning permission and the introduction of variable ridge heights and dormer windows would disrupt the simple and cohesive design of the approved scheme. This would be harmful to the character and appearance of the surrounding area. Unit 2 and Unit 3 would have a shortfall in private outdoor amenity space significantly below the recommended minimum standard of 100 square metres. There was no energy statement and calculations submitted with the application.
In the appeal document from Woolf Bond Planning they state that “The gardens as proposed are commensurate with the character of the area; whilst neighbouring dwellings fronting Reading Road have gardens greater in length, they are narrower. Further along, the new dwellings addressed as Watermans Mews, 291 Reading Road, and behind in Farm Road, have notably short gardens. These referenced examples which are located in close proximity to the appeal site.”
There are no differences proposed in the approved and proposed footprints, and consequently the garden sizes would remain as approved. The only changes involve alterations to the roof design, which come about as a result of the proposed insertion of rooflights to make use of the attic space.”
Henley Town Council recommended refusal of the application too. They said, “The proposal is in conflict with several policies in the South Oxfordshire Local Plan, including delivering high quality development; enhancing local character due to the development failing to enhance the local character and residential amenity due to impact on neighbours. There are concerns that with four effectively 4-bedroom houses the parking would be insufficient and that the gardens would not provide sufficient amenity space for the residents.”












Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!