A Cut Above: The Three Tuns Reopens with Bold Flavours and Butcher-Backed Quality
Last weekend, the historic Three Tuns in Market Place reopened under the exciting new partnership between Gabriel Machin Butchers and Nigel Sutcliffe (owner of The Oarsman in Marlow). This collaboration brings together top butchery and refined gastropub flair—and we were lucky enough to be among the first to sample the results.
From the outset, it’s clear that quality ingredients are the cornerstone of the menu. Gabriel Machin’s premium cuts and thoughtfully sourced local produce shine throughout the dishes. The newly redecorated building offers a warm and relaxed atmosphere as you step inside.
We started with Half a Pint of Prawns, a generous and satisfying opener paired with a zesty Blood Mary Marie Rose sauce that balanced creaminess with a sharp tang. Alongside, the Salmon with Potato Salad was equally impressive with a generous serving of moist salmon accompanied by well-seasoned creamy potato salad topped with dill.
For mains, we chose the Bavette Steak with Béarnaise Sauce and the Confit Lamb Breast. The steak was a standout: tender, rich in flavour, and perfectly complemented by a velvety Béarnaise sauce. Crispy fries and a peppery rocket and mint salad rounded out the plate with contrasting textures and freshness.
The confit lamb was a triumph of texture and taste—fall-apart tender with aromatic notes of garlic and rosemary. It was accompanied by the ‘star on the plate’ carrot which, as the chef explained, was seasoned with white miso, tahini, coriander, chives, pickled shallots, and finished with a crunchy breadcrumb topping. A dramatic swirl of black garlic sauce added depth, tying the dish altogether.
The service was warm throughout, with Molly, the restaurant manager from The Oarsman, offering knowledgeable insight into the dishes and ensuring a relaxed, welcoming experience.
The back courtyard’s Stable Bar has been charmingly transformed into The Boat Shed, a new dining space ideal for private events. It’s also set to host a weekly Burger Night every Sunday from 5:30–8:45pm—a casual addition we’re eager to return for.
To finish – we enjoyed the decadent strawberry cheesecake —rich, creamy, and bursting with ripe strawberries. A perfect end to a beautifully executed meal.
In all, the rebirth of The Three Tuns marks an exciting evolution for Henley’s food scene. With expert butchery, inventive flavours, and a talented team at the helm, it’s a spot well worth visiting.

















Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!