Town Council Reviews Spending & Use of Listed Buildings
Town Councillors on the Recreation & Amenities Committee reviewed quotations for remedial works to the value of £600k on their Grade II listed buildings: Old Fire Station Gallery (OFSG), West Street Store (WSS) and the Fairmile Chapels last week. They decided to recommend the approval of the work of OFSG and WSS stores to Full Council and retender for the Chapels work.
Rupert Hilton and Elsa Sibley from Janus Conservation who drew up the tenders for the work explained to the Committee that due to market conditions, ongoing skills shortages and high workloads impacted contractor availability and only one contractor, DBR (London) Limited submitted compliant tenders. Both works came in at considerably more than the initial estimated costs.
The works at OFSG and WSS are to strip and recover the clay tile pitched roofs, repair exposed roof timbers, rainwater goods renewal, associated masonry, decorative repairs plus internal sound insulation. An independent quantity surveyor was appointed to analyse the costs and provide information to negotiate reducing the costs from £381K to £361K.
There were discussions at the meeting around only doing the re-roofing work at OFSG and WSS and whether once completed could West Street Store be sold off and developed into a dwelling to cover the cost. Rupert Hilton said, “It is highly unlikely that you would get permission to covert to a dwelling.” The Council despite having the roofing repairs in their Strategic Plan 2024 – 2029, they don’t have a planned use for WSS. It is currently used for storage of council equipment. Rupert suggested that perhaps they look at joining the OFSG and WSS to make a larger gallery space.
A quinquennial survey was carried out in 2019 on WSS for the Council which indicated that work was required to ensure that the building did not deteriorate structurally. A further condition survey was carried in March 2022. This advised that the building needed initial intervention within 12 months and more substantial intervention within the next 5 years. If a listed building goes into disrepair, then local and central government may force repairs to be carried out. If the works are not carried out by the owner, the authority has the power to enter the property, carry out the works and seek to recover the costs from the owner. The Council has reserved funds in their Capital Expenditure budget to cover the costs of these works.
The remedial works needed at the Fairmile Chapel and Columbarium are roof repairs, masonry cleaning and repairs, reduction of high external ground levels and re-grouting of internal tiled flooring. The Council spent £150K to restore the Fairmile Chapels and to convert one of them into the Columbarium in 2021. The quote from DBR (London) Limited was again reviewed by an independent quantity surveyor to analyse the costs and managed to reduce the quote from £368K to £240K.
Rupert Hilton from Janus Conservation advised that as the works are currently not urgent on the Chapels, it would be beneficial to retender the project to try and secure a more competitive bid. This was agreed by the R&A Committee.
Concerns were raised as to why the Columbarium roof needs repairing, as conversion works took place approximately five years ago. The Town Clerk and Estate Manager are to check the contract with the previous contractor and a site visit has been arranged.











Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!