Appeal to overturn planning permission for conversion of The Hub into flats
Hub Project Management Company are appealing SODC’s decision to refuse planning permission for the conversion of The Hub offices in Station Road into 25 flats. The appeal will take place starting at 10am on 30 September at Abbey House in Abingdon.
SODC refused permission in December 2024 with the following objections: loss of employment space, lack of affordable housing, large balconies overlooking Hewgate Court and Station Road homes, lack of amenity space, insufficient information about rain water drainage run-off, lack of site strategy for sustainable drainage systems and lack of 106 to secure infrastructure.
The application includes the addition of a third floor to the existing building. Over the years, the site has seen a number of controversial planning applications to convert the offices into apartments. In May 2018 SODC approved a Permitted Development Order (PDO) for 24 apartments. In October 2018, they submitted planning application for 24 apartments with an extra top floor housing 6 residential apartments which was refused by SODC. Ressance Limited of Newbury appealed SODC’s decision in January 2020 and this was dismissed in February 2020. In May 2021 SODC approved a PDO for 18 apartments which has now lapsed. In 2022 a PDO was submitted and approved in July 2023 for an extension of the building to provide additional flats for a total of 25.
Hub PMC like many planning appeals against SODC currently are stating the Council cannot now demonstrate a sufficient five-year housing land supply. The appeal also sets out the benefits from a PDO to convert the the offices into 18 flats in August 2021 and another to create a further 7 flats in July 2023.
Henley Town Council recommended refusal of the application by stating “There are strong concerns over the design of the proposal including the overall size and the potential overlooking on neighbouring properties especially from the proposed balconies and adverse impact on light.”
A report from Simmons and Sons has been submitted by Hub PMC to substantiate against the commercial viability of the office space. SODC however state in their appeal report that “The council does not consider that the marketing of two suites constitutes “the site”. Indeed, the appellant acknowledges that the marketing that has been undertaken does not relate to the entire office block.
There are other office suites in The Hub that are owner occupied or have been marketed by other agents.”
Amended plans have been submitted to the appeal regarding the large balconies. These have been removed from rear elevation on the third floor but remain on the first and second floors.
Only 13 of the 25 flats will have balconies and 2 ground floor flats have outdoor space. Hub PMC argue that scheme is located within a town centre location within a highly accessible area, with
access to large public open space and under the General Permitted Development Order obtained the dwellings could be provided without such private or communal amenity space.
A Financial Viability Appraisal, prepared by S106 Management by Hub PMC says this demonstrates that on a 100% open market basis, the benchmark land value exceeds the residual land value of the scheme. Therefore, the development cannot viably provide the targeted affordable housing. A SODC Consultant reviewed the appraisal and confirmed “that the development would be rendered unviable if affordable housing was required to be delivered in accordance with development plan policy.”
With regard to the rain water drainage and sustainable drainage systems, SODC say, “In the light of the information submitted with the appeal, the council is satisfied in both scenarios that the scheme offers betterment, and there will be no increase in flood risk elsewhere.”
You can still comment on this appeal by going to https://acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ and using the appeal reference 3367360
The decision is expected to be issued on or before 25 November 2025





Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!