Councillor Hinton found in breach of Code of Conduct over 5G mast comments
A panel has ruled that Councillor Kellie Hinton breached the councillors’ Code of Conduct in relation to remarks she made about a controversial planning application for a 5G mast on Makins Recreation Ground.
The complaint against Councillor Hinton was that she made disrespectful and inflammatory remarks in a press interview referring to objectors of the mast as “bunch of Nimbys” and a “bunch of crackpot wannabe scientists” and suggesting that residents should be grateful the land was not being turned back into landfill.
Following social media posts by Ms B, it was alleged that Councillor Hinton responded with aggressive and dismissive comments, including memes and public replies that could be perceived as bullying and humiliating. Councillor Hinton used her official council email address and signature in subsequent correspondence on the matter, further blurring the lines between personal opinion and her role as an elected representative.
Ms W’s complaint focused on public interactions on Facebook, where she felt belittled and insulted by Councillor Hinton, who allegedly called her a liar and made insinuations intended to embarrass her and suppress her participation in local campaigns.
Councillor Hinton did not attend the hearing but was represented by Councillor Ken Arlett who read out a statement from Councillor Hinton.
The panel hearing reviewed the evidence and agreed that Councillor Hinton failed to show respect to others and brought her role or authority into disrepute. However, they found the balance was marginally in favour of Councillor Hinton not having been acting in her capacity as a Councillor when making her comments on Facebook. After reviewing the Facebook evidence and views of an independent person, it was the Panel’s view that the behaviour did not reach the threshold required to constitute bullying and therefore did not amount to a breach.
Afterwards the panel agreed that Councillor Hinton should submit a formal written apology to the complainants, required to attend training on social media and respect, she should remove all social media comments relating to the topics covered by the complaint and she will be directed to discuss learning points and expected behaviours with her political leaders after the learning from the above.
You can read the full decision notice here











Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!