Planning Inspectors recommend Joint Plan 2041 be withdrawn
Planning Inspectors have this week recommended that the South & Vale Joint Plan 2041 is withdrawn due to the ‘duty to co-operate’ (DtC) with Oxford City Council on the residual unmet need of housing in their own local plan.
Historically, there has been close collaboration and joint working between the local planning authorities in Oxfordshire in relation to plan making and the approach to identifying housing needs. In December 2023, Oxford City Council wrote to each of the Oxfordshire authorities to formally ask whether those authorities would be able to meet any of the residual unmet need 2,528 homes (20-20-2040).
In the Inspectors report it states, “In summary, potential unmet housing need for Oxford City beyond 2031/36 and how the JLP accommodates previously agreed unmet need are strategic matters and, therefore, fall under the DtC. Consequently, the Councils should have engaged constructively, actively and on an on-going basis on the issues. Whilst there were some early attempts at engagement, for the period between January 2024 and November 2024 meaningful engagement on this issue did not occur outside of the formal examination process.” The city council itself was forced to withdraw its own local plan from examination earlier this year on several issues regarding the duty to co-operate.
Cllr David Rouane, Leader of South Oxfordshire District Council, said: “We are disappointed but not surprised given recent rulings from Planning Inspectors nationally – an increasing number of emerging local plans around the country are being recommended for withdrawal for this issue in particular; Horsham and Mid Sussex spring to mind as recent examples.
“We developed a constructive and collaborative plan and engaged with the city through a variety of methods, even when there was clear disagreement over both the need and the approach. It is not clear what more we could have done on this front.
“Our approach to measuring housing need was in line with the Inspectors of Oxford’s plan last year. Since our examination hearings in June, Oxford’s latest local plan consultation shows that using the government’s standard method there would be no more homes for us to find for Oxford.
“There are aspects of the Inspectors’ letter that we’re keen to review, but our most important role is to ensure where we can that we represent our communities and their needs.”
The councils are in discussions about the next steps and will provide a further update in due course.
You can read the full Inspectors’ letter here: Inspectors’ letter.





Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!