Shiplake New Road development refused by SODC
A proposed housing development by WoolfBond to build 25 homes on land next to New Road in Shiplake was rejected by SODC planning committee on Wednesday by 7 votes to 1.
The Planning Officer Phil Moule recommended that the application should be approved because “the benefits provided by the proposed development (that would deliver against all of the benefits that are recognised and emphasised in the National Planning Policy Framework) would not be outweighed by the harm caused to the objectives of the neighbourhood plan and the localised residual harm to the attractive rural setting of Lower Shiplake” despite the site not being in the Shiplake Neighbourhood Plan.
In his report, the Planning Officer said, “In terms of the benefits of the scheme, 25 dwellings would be provided which would make a meaningful contribution to the council’s lack of supply of deliverable housing sites. This would include 10 affordable homes. These are greater benefits than the previous two appeal schemes on the smaller part of the site that is a paddock, that
were dismissed.”
Chair of Shiplake Parish Council criticised the Planning Officer’s report on how it missed important parts of Parish Council’s objections and how the proposal contravened the Neighbourhood Plan. He said at the meeting, “It’s contradiction of the absolute vision of our neighbourhood plan. The proposal undermines our vision to maintain Shiplake’s rural character and the separation of its villages. It is breach of our core objectives preserving the rural setting, a distinct identity of our villages, preventing elongation to open countryside and protecting agricultural land between our settlements. Afterwards he added, “I challenged the recommendation because it would therefore render all NPs useless and lead to more speculative development in Shiplake that had suffered enough. I also spoke about a technical Planning matter, the misapplication of the tilted balance.”
Neighbouring Shiplake resident, Karen Cooper spoke on behalf of 96 residents who objected to the planning application. She asked for Councillors to reject the proposal under SODC’s Local Plan Policy H8 which states that “smaller villages ‘have no defined requirement to contribute towards delivering additional housing (beyond windfall and infill development) to meet the overall housing requirement of South Oxfordshire.” and Policy H16 on Infill developments “Where a proposal encompasses residential development of land behind an existing frontage or placing of further dwelling/s behind existing dwelling/s within the existing site, the proposals should demonstrate that 1) the privacy of existing and future residents will be protected; ii) means of access can be appropriately secured; and iii) development would not extend the built limits of the settlement.
Douglas Gold spoke on behalf of developer Woolf Bond who said, “This application has been carefully prepared to ensure high quality housing scheme is delivered addressing all technical issues but meeting the housing needs that the District requires. I know the proposal is unpopular with residents but it is important to step back for a second and acknowledge the housing challenges facing the Council.”
Shiplake Parish Council’s District Councillor, Leigh Rawlins underlined the problems with the site, the misapplication of the tilted balance with good local knowledge of the unsuitability of the road for walking and driving, and getting to the school 1.2km away without footpaths. He also criticised the Officer’s use of drought condition photographs of New Road.
The application was refused with all Councillors voting against it apart from Councillor Ken Arlett who said, “I think it is a good application. I would be surprised if they appeal they don’t get it.”





Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!