Henley Town Council has unanimously passed a motion opposing the proposed closure of Henley Fire Station, citing serious concerns about the impact on emergency response times and public safety. The decision was made at the Town & Communities Committee meeting held on Tuesday night.
Councillors highlighted that if the station were to close, response times for house fires and road traffic accidents could increase from 7–10 minutes to over 20 minutes if coming from Caversham, with some locations seeing delays of up to 31 minutes from Wallingford. The council also expressed concern that reliance on fire crews from Caversham and Crowmarsh would compromise emergency coverage, and that Oxfordshire residents should be served primarily by their Oxfordshire fire service.
Oxfordshire County Council have issued a report as part of the consultation. According to County Councillor Stefan Gawrysiak who reviewed the data contained within the report against data held at the fire station, which includes:
Reported Henley call-outs of 67, when the true figure is understood to be 110
Crew availability cited as 9%, while the true range is 36–57%
Omission of deployment times for critical incidents
Failure to recognize that Henley accounts for 34% of all call-outs in South Oxfordshire, the busiest area in the district
Henley Town Council has formally called on Chief Fire Officer Rob Macdougall and Councillor Jenny Hannaby to:
Withdraw misleading data from the consultation
Replace it with accurate and verifiable information
Publish deployment times for Henley before and after any potential closure
Attend a council meeting in person to explain the decision-making process
The council is now encouraging local residents to have their say in the consultation to ensure their views are heard and that decisions are based on accurate information.
It is lunacy to deprive an expanding town like Henley and its environment of a Fire Fighting
Force in the centre of town. We seem to be gradually persuaded that a reduction in services is progress: no banks, few cash points, post offices at the rear of confectionery, occasional
police stations etc. The distances and the complexity of country roads in this locality makes
it essential for a fire service hub in Henley. Whatever money saving strategies are fuelling
this issue, fire services like ambulance services save lives – saving money should not be the
criterion.
There are three issues here:
1. Recruiting retained fire-fighters is getting harder and harder, across the country. People have less slack in their daily lives to give over to responding to pagers, The days are gone wen the blacksmith, butcher and candlestick maker could drop everything and help man a local appliance. Pressure of personal time, turnout travel times and the raised recruitment standards all limit the recruitment pool. If we, the residents of Henley, want to keep our pump then we, the residents, have to stand forward to man it. Furthermore employers near the station have to consider how they might release employees to assist, especially during the working day, when the station struggles for personnel.
2. Over recent decades Royal Berkshire closed a number of stations (Cookham, Pangbourne, Sonning, Wargrave) These last two fell by the wayside for identical reasons. At the time, we were all assured that Henley would take up the slack in Sonning and Wargrave, and all would be well. Despite being different brigades Buck Berks and Oxon now share one control. We need to challenge that control on how wide they feel the net of Caversham Road might be cast, as it’s getting larger by the day. Consider. also that Caversham runs the nearest fire boat, switch manned with their pump. So that reduces the resilience of any river borne incident in what is probably the most famous bit of river.
2. Oxfordshire F&RS produced some odd figures to support the closure argument. Yes, as I said above, day cover is always a challenge for retained stations. But it is during the night, when the pump is available, that we all sleep in our beds. Lies, damned lies and statistics comes to mind.
Lets not let the bean counters win. But the youth of the town must stand-up and volunteer for fire service.
The Vole.