Appeal allowed for 5G Mast to be installed at Makins Recreation Ground
The proposed 5G mast at Makins Recreation ground has been allowed to proceed after the Planning Inspectorate approved this at the appeal.
Telent Technology Services, on behalf of EE, submitted an application to install a 20m high monopole in December last year. The plans were recommended to be refused by the Town Council and refused by SODC in February; however, the decision was appealed by Telent in March.
Despite SODC refusing the planning application on the grounds of “siting and height would be visually intrusive and incongruous, and would detract from the character and appearance of the site and its surroundings, and the amenity of adjacent residential occupiers and users of the Makins Recreation Ground” the Planning Inspectorate concluded in his report by saying “The siting and appearance of the proposed mast would give rise to unacceptable harm to the character and visual quality of the area. Nonetheless, in light of the absence of any more suitable alternative site within the required coverage zone, this harm is outweighed by the significant social and economic benefits associated with enhanced telecommunications provision. Accordingly, the appeal should be allowed, and prior approval is granted.”
The Town Council who own the land applied for registration of recreation ground to become a Town Green like Gillotts Field and Freeman’s Meadow in April this year. This normally a straight forward process and should only take a month to process however there has been some delay at South Oxfordshire District Council. A spokesperson for the Council said, “There is currently a restriction on the title register following a grant for a skatepark some time ago. Officers from SODC are working to grant consent. We are in contact with the town council and keeping them updated with progress.”
Active campaigner against the mast Charlotte Wolfe responded to the decision: “This is a really appalling decision by the Planning Inspectorate. They themselves say that the mast will cause unacceptable harm to the area. They have accepted at face value Telent’s assertion that the fire station is unsuitable – Telent did not provide proof or look at how the tower could be reinforced. Most importantly, Telent’s appeal contains lies about the location of the mast. They have implied to the Planning Inspectorate that it will be located in their original choice of the carpark by the skate park, but the newest plans place it right by houses at the top of the hill. I hope someone is able to take this to the High Court and fight it.”
Neighbouring resident, Jonathan Lake added, “Very disappointed. Most of us appreciate the consumer demand for connectivity and the need for network densification. This appeal decision highlights the lack of a coherent strategy for where these masts are located or any approach to mast sharing contrary to the UK’s National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) . We are seeing masts pop up now all over the town from different operators (top shops and Tesco roundabout recent examples) and the appeal decision doesn’t appear to consider alternative sites, or even use the existing facilities such as the fire station and just takes what the telecoms provider states at face value.
“If we had a coherent approach with mast sharing, investment in the use of existing mast facilities, then we could all gain the social, economic benefits in a way that is not damaging to our town. We all know that Makins Rec sits in an elevated position, its our local green space and this structure is overbearing, will create a visual intrusion and cause unacceptable harm to the character of the area.
“This is very disappointing for the town and makes a mockery of the planning process. The opinions and feedback from people stated in the planning process has been ignored.”
Chair of Gainsborough Association and Town Councillor, David Eggleton said, “I’m disappointed that people of Henley are not being listened to. In Councils and organisations, we always listen to people and give them chance to vote on things. It’s the way things are with being dealt with at the moment, it seems that people don’t have a voice. The way this application was handled was all wrong – only 5 or 6 houses were notified about it and the Town Council first said they can’t do anything about it. We can always do something about it. We should fight in what you believe, rather than sit back and say you can’t change it. Why was the location moved from the corner of Headway? I didn’t see anything about this go through committee? Telent said they reviewed 30 locations for the mast. I asked the question why none of the other locations were suitable but didn’t get an answer. We wanted to register the recreation ground as Town Green, why has it taken so long? Again I didn’t get an answer. It doesn’t sound right. The Town Council should be pressing for this Town Green status as they have invested in this green space by spending thousands on the skatepark, basketball court, football and outdoor gym. The view from the park is beautiful and putting this monstrous thing up will completely spoil it. They say it will be obscured by the trees but what will happen when the leaves are not on the trees. I wish the Japanese Knotweed was still there as they wouldn’t be able to touch it. The affect on people’s health too – we have not seen any evidence that it is 100% safe. In 10 or 20 years, who knows what problems it is going to cause? It will definitely interfere with wildlife – we have bats and owls there – are they are going to still be there, wiped out or have to go somewhere else? Not enough research by the Council has gone into this.”
“We all need mobile phones because it is the way things are advancing, We have started to reverse things that we did 20 years ago like changing glass things to plastic. What’s to say this isn’t going to be reversed and destroying other things in the process. If we are relying on these devices, we’re not living and we’re not used our brains as much as we used to. It’s not good.”
“Makins who gave the land would be turning in his grave as he gave it to be used as recreation ground. What’s to say that once the mast is installed that they continue to add to this if there aren’t conditions in place.”
A spokesperson for Henley Town Council said “We are disappointed that the Appeal has been allowed, given the significant concerns raised by residents and councils about the mast’s impact on Makins. The decision is outside the Town Council’s control though and the Planning Inspector’s decision is now final. Our role now is to ensure that residents’ concerns continue to be heard and that any installation is carried out with the least possible impact on the surrounding area.”











Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!