Shiplake New Road planning appeal dismissed
The planning appeal by Woolf Bond Planning Ltd against South Oxfordshire District Council’s refusal of 25 new homes to be built on land off New Road in Shiplake has been turned down.
SODC refused the application in October 2025 on three reasons:
- It is not infill development and it is not located within the settlement of Shiplake or the built-up area defined in the neighbourhood plan.
- The proposed development would be in conflict with the core objective and policies of the neighbourhood plan to conserve and enhance the essential rural character of the parish.
- The site is not considered a sustainable location in relation to transport and infrastructure.
Plus there was no 106 agreement in place to secure affordable housing and infrastructure to meet the needs of the development and meet the net gain of biodiversity of 10% or more. A Unilateral Undertaking (UU) planning obligation was submitted to the appeal providing a legal agreement to secure affordable housing and the contribution towards biodiversity.
The appeal lead by Inspectorate K Stephens turned down the appeal on the basis that the site does not lie within the village, the site is not sustainable in terms of transport infrastructure and the development of the site would see loss of Lower Shiplake’s essential rural character.
He outweighed the appellant’s objection that SODC does not have a five-year supply of housing land by stating “I am cognisant of the Council’s view that paragraph 14 does apply because the Local Plan states that Smaller Villages do not have to contribute to the district’s housing requirement. As both villages have a zero housing requirement, they do not need to have housing allocations.”
The Shiplake Neighbourhood Plan was influential in the Inspectorate’s decision. He said, “I do not need to establish if the site lies within the village, because the site is not in the Green Belt and because the recently made Shiplake Neighbourhood Plan clearly identifies a BUA boundary for the village of Lower Shiplake for planning purposes and shows the appeal site lies outside it.”
After walking from the site along varies pathways and roads, Mr Stephens concluded, “I am of the view that the proposal would not actively encourage walking and cycling and that the proposal would fail to prioritise pedestrian/cyclist movements, fail to materially improve the pedestrian and cycling environment to make it safe and attractive for all users and thus the site’s location would not be sustainable in terms of transport infrastructure.”





Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!