Overwhelming opposition at packed meeting to save fire station
A packed Christ Church Centre hosted the Public Meeting to learn more about, and take questions on, the Consultation on proposals to improve Oxfordshire Fire and Rescue Service. It was standing room only, and not much of that, as residents, councillors and business owners came to show their overwhelming support for the Henley Fire Station, which is recommended for closure in the proposals made by the Oxfordshire service.
Rob Mac Dougall, Oxfordshire’s Chief Fire Officer (who has served for 27 years), gave a summary of the proposal – of which the main aim is to reduce deployment times across the county. In order to achieve this, he explained, there would be some shift restructuring, requiring the re-allocation of staff to provide 5 more day-shift stations. The proposal also includes plans to build a new station in north Oxford, remove an engine from Thame and the closure of 3 of the county’s fire stations with their buildings available to be sold off. Eynsham, Woodstock and most controversially, Henley, have been deemed to have “persistent low fire engine availability”, low percentages of turn outs and to have issues recruiting on-call firefighters – affecting their abilities to form a crew. He stressed that no decisions had been made yet but that the meeting was not part of the consultation, so views must be submitted via the online survey – which closes on 20 January.
First to speak was Chris Wycherley of the Fire Brigades Union (FBU). His opening remarks spoke about how the planned closure was a “disaster for fire fighters and residents alike.” He informed the public that the union had been given no prior knowledge of the document and proposals, there had been no consultation with them and indeed, they had had less than 24 hours to see and digest the proposal before its launch. He also claimed that the report, which is based on data and computer programming software recommendations, appears to be based on flawed data – a statement later backed up by Cllr. Stefan Gawrysiak. “What is needed is investment not closure. Fire is not governed by data alone.” He also pointed out that the Henley crews were not allowed to speak out and had effectively been gagged. He closed by calling for everyone to “stand up for yourselves and public safety.”
Cllr. Gawrysiak took to the lectern and thanked all those firefighters present for their service in the dangerous job they do, as well as all the people attending for showing their support. He highlighted the petition that has also been started and currently sits at 2000 signatures and urged residents to sign as well. Henley Town Council are unanimously opposed to the decision to close the fire station stating “The move would significantly endanger local residents by dramatically increasing emergency response times.” Cllr. Gawrysiak, along with his OCC colleague Cllr. Rawlins, explained that they found that the flawed data Chris Wycherley discussed was so because the data used in the consultation contained no granular data for Henley. As a town close to the border of the county, Henley serves the area from Playhatch to Medmenham and Hurley to Nuffield including Wargrave and Hambleden – however, cross border shouts have not been included in the data. In the report, the stated number of attended shouts was 66 – corrected to 77 a month later, however, the data received by Cllr. Gawrysiak shows that in 2024/25 there were 171 incidents and in 2025, 153. The data used in the report was from 2022/23 (during Covid). He also disputed the use of response times. The report gives an average change in response times in the county as 1 second. However, in reality, the current response times based on the data recently received were: Henley crew = 8 minutes (average), Caversham Road Crew = 14 minutes (average), 18+ to get to central Henley – an unacceptable rise according to Cllr. Gawrysiak.
“We want a day crew station with full time fire fighters serving 8-8pm, not to lose our fire station! For a proposal that is supposedly about response times, not cost cutting, why spend £8million on a new station at Crowmarsh when we already have a perfectly good one here! Invest not cut!”
Cllr. Rawlins spoke in support of Cllr Gawrysiak’s findings and also to say that he wanted to see improvements in the fire service and that reviews were necessary, however there was too much emphasis on averages and that county border stations like Henley were much too complex to be decided by data.
Freddie Van Mierlo, also in attendance said “I agree wholeheartedly with everything said so far. This proposal is built on blancmange, not rocks, it just doesn’t add up! It makes sense to check resources are being used effectively but the response times will be so much worse. It feels like Henley is being sold down the river at the expense of the rest of Oxfordshire. Minutes matter when you are talking about fire and I want the best deal for the whole of my constituency, not to see Henley at a disadvantage.”
Instead of addressing the audience, Henley’s Mayor, Cllr. Tom Buckley addressed Rob Mac Dougall. “I don’t need to speak to the people gathered here because I represent them. I want to speak directly to you.” He explained how he works in IT day in and day out. He expressed his view that the modelling used has major failings. “We are not an average place, in an average situation – you can’t rely on averages for our future. We are in a rural area, but we are not a rural town. I would like the proposal to be withdrawn and re-evaluated. We are not statistics, we are real people on real streets.”
After an hour of passionate presentations and heartfelt speeches, questions were taken from the public – although there was not enough time for all to be heard so those that didn’t get to speak were encouraged to email their questions for a reply.
Questions covered a number of topic areas. Firstly, there was a query over the timing of the consultation (including the Christmas period in the schedule) and the seemingly little effort made to ensure the document reached a wide audience. It was also questioned as to why this was being done prior to the expected changes in the structures of the local councils. A resident of Caversham (whose fire engines would be expected to cover the Henley area if the closure was made) pointed out that the Caversham Road station now only had one engine, and was also the busiest station in Berkshire, therefore it was supplemented by Wokingham Road when already out on a shout. He also disputed the transparency, when any comments made online about the document are not able to be seen by other people – as is usually the case.
One fire fighter from North Oxford talked about Exhausted Crew Syndrome, a concern he had if shift patterns were changed. He also stated two similar projects that had undergone similar modelling using the same type of data (one with the Essex fire service) – which he went on to state had failed. He questioned relying on modelling that had previously failed. In response, Rob Mac Dougall stated that he was confident in the modelling and there were other services where the modelling had worked.
Rosie Gosby-Dolby, wife of fire-fighter Andy Gosby, spoke passionately about hers and her husband’s work. She explained that they had been working hard to recruit, but that it wasn’t actually part of their job and they received no support when they asked for it. She explained how the data they have to log in the watch books is significantly different to the data in the proposal. She also talked about the affect on mental health – of the fire fighters fighting for their station, community and their jobs, but also that of their families. She explained how she had been surrounded in a shop and asked questions she just couldn’t answer as they aren’t allowed to speak about details. How residents were in fear of what would happen to them without a fire station in Henley – and how she sat in her car and cried for 30 mins afterwards.
In response, Rob commended the work of Henley fire station and said that Oxfordshire remained committed to supporting the mental health of their employees. He said that any employer had a code of conduct that employees have to work to and this was why speaking out against the employer wasn’t allowed.
Andy Gosby, whose family has worked at Henley for 60 years (himself serving 20!) spoke to say that he had challenged the data and received a ‘sorry, that was a typo’. He said “It’s simple – if Henley stays we have a response time of 8 minutes. If Henley goes the response time will be 18 minutes. That’s not improved deployment times.”
Read the full consultation document here: Consultation Document
Survey responses: online survey – closes on 20 January.
Sign the petition against closure: petition














Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!