Taylor Wimpey disputes risk to drinking water supply at planning appeal
The Thames Farm planning appeal by Taylor Wimpey concluded last week after nine days of evidence, technical debate, and legal submissions on the planning applications to build 84 homes on the Reading Road site. The appeal was against SODC’s refusal of the associated conditions for the drainage system and associated stabilising groundworks.
South Oxfordshire District Council and a Rule 6 party representing Henley, Shiplake and Harpsden gave evidence to oppose the appeal.
A major point of contention was whether proposed grouting techniques could safely stabilise the site without risking contamination of the underlying drinking water aquifer. The opposition argued the approach was largely untested in such conditions and carried significant uncertainty, while the developer maintained risks were minimal and manageable.
Witness experts debated the viability of the drainage design that was a pumped system and detention basin which would collect all the surface water from the site including the highways into the basin which would be c 4m above the houses. The opposition experts described the scheme as overly complex, potentially unadoptable, and designed to maximise housing density rather than reflect site constraints. The developer’s experts defended the technical design, arguing that mitigation measures, monitoring, and engineering controls would ensure safety. Their witnesses however acknowledged that they had limited direct experience of similar grouting projects in sensitive aquifer conditions.
The developer emphasised the local housing shortfall and the need for development under national planning policy, while SODC highlighted the importance of the local neighbourhood plan and environmental protections.
The proposed 6-metre investigation grid instead of 3-metre grid for the ground stabilisation works was confirmed to be cost-driven, potentially increasing the risk of missing underground voids. Questions were raised about compliance with environmental guidance and the potential impact of high-alkaline grout on drinking water. The adoption and long-term responsibility for drainage infrastructure remained unclear.
A round table session ended the hearing where a review of potential planning conditions was discussed in case the appeals are approved. For the drainage application these included no works started until the flood water basin has been constructed, the pumping station is completed and operational and an Environmental Permit is obtained to protect the groundwater source protection zone. For the ground stabilisation works no development shall commence on site until full details of the grout mixture have been provided, the precise type and composition of the cement and a scheme of works have been submitted to demonstrate how it will be ensured that no grouting shall take place within a distance of 2m from the water table.
The inspector, Mr Matthew Shrigley conducted a site visit on day 7 of the appeal hearing and he indicated a decision is expected by mid-May 2026.











Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!