Councils’ knowledge gaps contributed to Land Charges delays
A lack of organisational knowledge within South Oxfordshire and Vale of White Horse District Councils was a key contributing factor to delays caused by the implementation of a new Local Land Charges (LLC) system, a scrutiny review has found.
The Joint Scrutiny Committee of the two councils reviewed the implementation of the new system last week, following disruption which delayed house moves and caused uncertainty for residents, businesses and professionals relying on Land Charges searches.
The review found that the councils had limited knowledge of the wider LLC operating environment, including system dependencies, processes, workflows and contractual arrangements.
It said that the combination of long-established systems and outsourced service delivery had, over time, reduced the councils’ ability to independently assess risks, challenge assumptions and fully understand the complexity involved in moving to a replacement system.
The review also found that, while the councils’ management of the outsourced LLC service had been sufficient during normal operations, greater officer oversight, direction and control would have been beneficial during such a significant service transformation project.
Ownership and accountability for systems, data and supplier relationships were not sufficiently defined, the review found. This resulted in limited visibility of some aspects of the service and reduced the councils’ ability to respond quickly when problems emerged.
At the meeting, councillors questioned historic decisions around the continuation of the outsourced arrangements and the procurement of replacement systems.
Officers explained that the original replacement system had ultimately proved incapable of delivering the required functionality, despite assurances given during the procurement process.
A further procurement exercise was therefore required, leaving less time to implement a new system before the council’s outsourced IT arrangements ended.
Officers stressed that the supplier of the new system had successfully delivered the elements it was contracted to provide. They said the principal problem was the councils’ incomplete understanding of historic customisation, integrations and dependencies within the much older legacy system.
They also noted that natural staff turnover may have affected the amount of knowledge retained about the legacy system.
The review was intended to examine the implementation of the project, including its planning, processes and the challenges encountered, and identify whether disruption could have been reduced.
A joint statement from Cllr Maggie Filipova-Rivers, Leader of South Oxfordshire District Council, and Cllr Bethia Thomas, Leader of Vale of White Horse District Council, said:
“We thank the Scrutiny Committee for their input and questioning as part of the candid process of examining the Land Charges project, and welcome their reflections on the report and their recommendations for the future.
“We want to be as transparent as possible on the reasons behind the delays to our Land Charges upgrade. We fully recognise the frustration and uncertainty this has caused for residents, businesses and professionals who rely on this service.
“Whilst we cannot change the past, we can be as open as possible in the reasons behind the delays and set out in detail what we can learn from the experience, to ensure any future service transformation projects are managed as effectively as possible.
“The report reflected on the implementation of this project, including the processes, planning and challenges encountered, to understand if disruption could have been reduced.
“It also aimed to provide some reassurance our service has effective arrangements in place to restore our search turnaround times to the target eight working days. We are pleased to report that these arrangements have had a positive impact, and we have cleared the backlog.
“We offer our sincere apologies to everyone who has been impacted by the downtime of our Land Charges system. Thank you again to everyone for your patience and understanding.”










Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!