EE Appeal Against Refusal of Planning for 5G Mast on Makins
Telent on behalf of EE have lodged an appeal against SODC’s decision to object to the planning permission for the 5G mast with 6 antennas and 2 dishes on Makins Recreation Ground.
The appeal will now be reviewed by the Planning Inspectorate.
In the appeal document, it states “The grounds of appeal rest on three matters:
1. The proposal in terms of scale would be acceptable and not appear incongruous to the area or upon residential, visual amenity and the users of the Makins Recreation Ground.
2. The proposed location to which this appeal relates would be acceptable and that it has been adequately demonstrated that there are no less detrimental alternatives than the appeal site.
3. That the impacts from the proposal are, in any event, acceptable. If harm is identified, it is outweighed by the significant social and economic benefits associated with the proposal and the operational and technological constraints (very special circumstances).”
It goes on to say, “The Council (SODC) have failed to understand is that such matters are not for consideration on prior approval applications (therefore are misapplying planning policy to the proposal) as planning permission has already been granted by Parliament under Article 3(1) of the GPDO and so the issue of inappropriate development and the related test of very special circumstances (either for green belt or local green spaces) cannot apply. The only issues that the Council can consider are siting and appearance, and Green Belt/local green space planning policy is not applicable.”
EE state that “numerous residents have complained about a distinct lack of coverage/capacity within the area and there are extensive dropped calls in the area.”
Gainsborough resident, Charlotte Wolfe who set up the campaign to object to the mast said, “Telent’s appeal brings no new reasoning as to why they can’t fix the fire station – which they state is “ideally located”. In fact, in the appeal they say that they provided a “full comprehensive discounted options list”, yet two of those options are described as “believed to be an in-building solution”. They believe? That’s hardly robust comprehensive research. And their reasons for (thankfully) discounting Freemans Meadows are just as true for Makins Recreation Ground. They also say that the mast will be 50m away from housing which isn’t true. This lie appears to come from the fact that they make two false claims in the appeal that the council has contradicted itself between the pre-application advice and the refusal of planning permission with regards to the suitability of the location of the mast. But in the pre-application the site of the mast was next to the skate park, and now it’s right next to the houses at Gainsborough Hill and Haywards Close.









Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!