Thames Farm Ground Stabilisation Works Refused Planning
Despite the SODC’s Planning Officer recommending approval of the Thames Farm ground stabilisation works planning application, the Planning Committee voted to refuse this last night due to the impact it could have on the drinking water supply aquifer.
The proposed ground stabilisation works were needed when the building work was put on hold in October 2020 after it was discovered that the chalk bedrock could not drain away the surface water through soakaways as originally planned as it was prone to developing sink holes. The works would have involved topsoil being excavated and stockpiled on the site, drilling of a series of boreholes across the identified areas at approximate six metre spacing and injecting a stiff mix grout to provide strength and compaction of the weakened subsurface.
During the meeting, Councillors heard from Deputy Chair of Shiplake Parish Council, District Ward Councillor Leigh Rawlins, Peter Boros from Thames Farm Action Group (TFAG), MP Freddie Van Mierlo against the application and Robin Shepherd Agent for Taylor Wimpey.
Deputy Chair of Shiplake Parish Council, Michael Pheasant said, “There is lack of scientific evidence from Taylor Wimpey on the impact of the drinking water supply.”
Henley & Thame MP, Freddie Van Mierlo said, “I want to add my voice of concerns. There is very real risk to the sole supply of drinking water. There is no contingency plan if the worst is realised.”
Robin Shepherd, Director at Stantec and acting Agent for Taylor Wimpey said there had been “no objections from the EA, Thames Water or the (SODC) Drainage Officer” and they had been “informed by leading experts to protect the water supply”. He added, “The level of risk has diminished. No one will ever say that there is no risk. The grouting method is well known, is tried and tested in the UK and overseas.”
After questioning the speakers, a debate followed which questioned the lack of reports from Thames Water and the EA, the size of area the aquifer covers, contamination of the water supply by the grout and the source protection strategy not being supplied or approved.
Councillor Jo Robb proposed the refusal of application and was seconded by Henley District Councillor Ken Arlett.
Paula Fox SODC Development Manager – Larger Sites then asked the Councillors to vote on the resolution “The key concern is the impact on the drinking water supply and if not withstanding the views of our expert consultees, which includes statutory consultees (EA and Thames Water) you are minded to vote against this application. I advise that you should refer to fact the site is underlaying by a principal aquifer and is within a groundwater source protection zone and to there being a public water abstraction for public water supply at a water treatment centre near the site.
“The application has failed to demonstrate that the proposed engineering operation and ground stabilisation works would not propose an unacceptable risk on the aquifer and the public water extraction.”
The vote saw 7 Councillors for, 1 abstain and 1 against.
The second application for the variations on the approved plans and landscape was deferred due to the first application being refused.
A Taylor Wimpey spokesperson said, “We worked closely with stakeholders and undertook extensive assessments in preparing these new planning applications for Thames Farm, Shiplake, which we believe provide robust responses to all concerns.
“We are therefore disappointed that South Oxfordshire District Council has resolved to refuse our application for engineering operations (grouting) to stabilise the land and deferred our application for the revised housing scheme for a delegated decision, despite officer support and no objections from statutory consultees.
“We will now consider our next steps.”











Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!