Appeal Dismissed for New Roofline on New Homes at Newtown Road
The Appeal against SODC’s refusal of a planning application to change the roofline on 4 new homes to be built on land the corner of Reading Road and Newtown Road has been dismissed by the Planning Inspectorate.
The developers, Knole Homes obtained planning approval for four new homes in April 2024 by SODC. They then submitted the revised application in December 2024 which was refused by SODC on 3 conditions, “The proposed development would have a significantly increased bulk and massing compared with the extant planning permission and the introduction of variable ridge heights and dormer windows would disrupt the simple and cohesive design of the approved scheme. This would be harmful to the character and appearance of the surrounding area. Unit 2 and Unit 3 would have a shortfall in private outdoor amenity space significantly below the recommended minimum standard of 100 square metres. There was no energy statement and calculations submitted with the application.”
The Planning Inspectorate dismissed the appeal on the grounds that, “The proposal seeks to change the approved mansard style roof for a hipped roof form. Despite a lower eave’s height, the proposal would increase the overall height of the building, making this appreciably taller than the approved scheme. Consequently, this would add considerable bulk and massing to the roof form of the proposed building. In particular, the taller and bulkier roof form of the proposed building would contrast starkly with the prevailing roof forms of buildings along Newtown Road. The proposed building with its revised roof form, would not reflect the buildings along Newtown Road and would detract from the street scene. As such, the proposal represents poor design and would harm the character and appearance of the area.”











Leave a Comment
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!